On CBS News: Check out today's news on Barack Obama
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

By Anne Broache, News.com
Posted on ZDNet News: May 19, 2006 4:12:00 PM

Faced with a patent infringement suit against the iPod and iPod Nano, Apple Computer countered this week with its own complaint against Creative Labs, which holds a distant second place in the personal media player market.

The suit was initiated in a Wisconsin federal court on May 15, the same day that the Singapore-based electronics maker said it had sued Apple in U.S. District Court in California, seeking an injunction against the iPod and damages.

In its complaint, Apple accuses the company of infringing on four of its patents related to user interfaces and icon displays for digital media players. The company is requesting monetary damages and an injunction barring continued use of its patents.

In a separate complaint with the U.S. International Trade Commission filed this week, Creative is also seeking an injunction that would stop Apple from selling the iPod and iPod Nano in the United States.

Creative's complaints center on a patent describing a system for organizing music and songs used in its Zen MP3 player, which the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office awarded it last August. The company's chief executive hinted a few months later that he planned to assert the company's patents against suspected infringers and seek royalties.

Apple declined to comment on Friday. Creative did not respond immediately to requests for comment.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 37 Talkback(s)
Creative should counter countersue
and then Apple can move it's checker pieces on the board. (Read the rest)
Posted by: Boot_Agnostic Posted on: 05/23/06 You are currently: Logged In | Log out
fight fight fight csa0307   | 05/19/06
patents are getting out of hand glocks out   | 05/19/06
patents are getting out of hand jamest74   | 05/19/06
RIght and wrong tic swayback   | 05/19/06
i agree glocks out   | 05/19/06
Patents ARE retroactive. mobrien_12@...   | 05/20/06
Then you agree with Bill Gates? No_Ax_to_Grind   | 05/20/06
Oh well, patents rule Boot_Agnostic   | 05/19/06
Just imagine mugsy!   | 05/19/06
patents are not permanent baggins_z   | 05/19/06
WTF have YOU ever copyrighted something? JaK_5quat   | 05/20/06
"Entitled" Artists? Mixotic   | 05/22/06
The creator isn't benefitting, his grandkids are. ajole   | 05/22/06
Software patents neil ubich   | 05/19/06
Make it too short and people will just wait to avoid fee's. Laff   | 05/19/06
Think about business process patents too tic swayback   | 05/19/06
You're all in trouble FNicodem   | 05/19/06
and you will backpay royalties to when the English langage invented Save_America   | 05/19/06
Apple needs to go bigjim01@...   | 05/19/06
Wow - You do know they develop/sell other products..... dave95.   | 05/19/06
bigjim01, I guess this is why ... lbarker@...   | 05/19/06
Which is also why the PC is the best computer, right? ajole   | 05/22/06
Re :Apple ericblr   | 05/20/06
Don't know what you are smoking but I want some!!!! Laff   | 05/20/06
hey don't mess up the rotation. spdrcrtob   | 05/21/06
I'm sorry.... spdrcrtob   | 05/21/06
All patents must die [nt] Omch'Ar   | 05/19/06
Patents webdevelopers   | 05/19/06
Hmmm, I wish Krazyken39   | 05/20/06
hmmm....he doesn't know spdrcrtob   | 05/21/06
Hey! Krazyken39   | 05/22/06
Actually, its more about the UI and the ease of use ajole   | 05/22/06
Ok now play nice...... Slycooper   | 05/20/06
Buy your iPod before the price goes up... ajole   | 05/22/06
If that's the case.... tic swayback   | 05/22/06
Uh oh!! Didn't think of that! ajole   | 05/22/06
Creative should counter countersue Boot_Agnostic   | 05/23/06

What do you think?

advertisement
advertisement