On TV.com: HEROES - Watch any episode from season 2
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

Posted on ZDNet News: Mar 15, 2006 6:25:00 AM

Reuters Logo Microsoft Chairman Bill Gates on Wednesday mocked a $100 laptop computer for developing countries being developed with the backing of rival Google at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

The $100 laptop project seeks to provide inexpensive computers to people in developing countries. The computers lack many features found on a typical personal computer, such as a hard disk and software.

Bill Gates Bill Gates

"The last thing you want to do for a shared use computer is have it be something without a disk...and with a tiny little screen," Gates said at the Microsoft Government Leaders Forum in suburban Washington, D.C.

"Hardware is a small part of the cost" of providing computing capabilities, he said, adding that the big costs come from network connectivity, applications and support.

Before his critique, Gates showed off a new "ultramobile computer" which runs Microsoft Windows on a seven-inch touch screen. Those machines are expected to sell for between $599 and $999, Microsoft said at the product launch last week.

"If you are going to go have people share the computer, get a broadband connection and have somebody there who can help support the user, geez, get a decent computer where you can actually read the text and you're not sitting there cranking the thing while you're trying to type," Gates said.

Gates described the computers as being for shared use, but the project goes under the name "One Laptop per Child." A representative for the project did not immediately reply to an inquiry seeking comment.

Earlier this year, Google founder Larry Page said his company is backing MIT's project. He showed a model of the machine that does use a crank as one source of power.

"The laptops ... will be able to do most everything except store huge amounts of data," according to the project's Web site.

Story Copyright © 2006 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved.

Story Copyright © 2006 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 233 Talkback(s)
no market share blues
Of course he is not in favor of it... he knows full well, he won't be selling $500 Office suites to people who can barely afford a $100 computer. But he's rich, so I say he should just pony up and bu... (Read the rest)
Posted by: shraven Posted on: 03/29/06 You are currently: Logged In | Log out
one would think Bill Gates would support... Arm A. Geddon   | 03/15/06
The reason he doesn't support it thilde   | 03/15/06
duh..didn't I just say that? Arm A. Geddon   | 03/15/06
excuse the spelling I was just a "tad" upset about this article. Arm A. Geddon   | 03/15/06
which world do you live in defconvegas   | 03/15/06
Seriously. A_Pickle   | 03/15/06
usually I'm not judgemental. Arm A. Geddon   | 03/15/06
not judgmental??? jeanjaz   | 03/17/06
No Sereourly. LittleGuy   | 03/16/06
You just can't do it, can you? balsover   | 03/16/06
Don't forget the IRS Dad13   | 03/17/06
I see voska   | 03/16/06
Percentage of disposable income...and tax breaks, of course gardoglee   | 03/16/06
Seriously Protagonistic   | 03/16/06
contributions? Arm A. Geddon   | 03/15/06
The $28 Bn number Yagotta B. Kidding   | 03/16/06
Federal Taxes... That's the thing steveknypstra   | 03/16/06
Drug dealers give a lot of money to the churches too, it does NOT make them DonnieBoy   | 03/16/06
Actually they give Billions... el1jones   | 03/16/06
You are upset? NonZealot   | 03/16/06
He's got a point though voska   | 03/16/06
exited? Arm A. Geddon   | 03/16/06
That isn't true. A_Pickle   | 03/15/06
Do you have any idea who many people this laptop MIGHT go too? Laff   | 03/16/06
Um... A_Pickle   | 03/16/06
Not in a world that generally means if you are impoverished Laff   | 03/16/06
Hit the nail on the head! tystoy1   | 03/16/06
The problem for MS here, is that Linux reduces the network effect. DonnieBoy   | 03/16/06
They need the whole software stack, and it must be free. DonnieBoy   | 03/16/06
would he donate win OS clockmendergb@...   | 03/16/06
So true, he is all for helping developing countries, AS LONG AS it does NOT DonnieBoy   | 03/16/06
Knock knock sbclied   | 03/16/06
RE: Knock knock (take your politics elsewhere) SteveH66   | 03/17/06
Do you remember the story about the guy and the............. Can you hear me   | 03/15/06
Perhaps you forget that it is MIT and Negroponte who are behind this gardoglee   | 03/16/06
Hardware is ALL the cost LateBlt   | 03/15/06
Hardware is less than half the cost. A_Pickle   | 03/15/06
my turn... Arm A. Geddon   | 03/15/06
While MIT and Microsoft are bickering, look at AMD nucrash   | 03/16/06
No, the open source stack is FREE, the cost to put an image on the DonnieBoy   | 03/16/06
70% hardware, 10% shipping, 20% Bribes ajole   | 03/16/06
Sounds like you're arguing against Bill maxsnorkel   | 03/16/06
Did you read your post? TonyMcS   | 03/16/06
Hmmm..Did you read it?? Northwolf   | 03/17/06
Uhhh, back on topic wanttaberacer   | 03/15/06
then maybe ZD dot NET should change the heading. Arm A. Geddon   | 03/15/06
either way these kind of articles make great flamebait. nt Arm A. Geddon   | 03/16/06
Giving laptops to 3rd world countries mrjonno   | 03/16/06
What do you think computers will be doing? Kessel Run   | 03/16/06
Yep joelmw_z   | 03/16/06
Laptop vs Textbook nucrash   | 03/16/06
I agree bill@...   | 03/16/06
Giving laptops to 3rd world countries mjbad2   | 03/17/06
Let Sun provide it, a blade for every child Boot_Agnostic   | 03/16/06
MIT v Gates in Rush to MArket sub-Saharan PC brian.smith@...   | 03/16/06
What is the cost to ms petra222   | 03/16/06
Message has been deleted. jayeholla   | 03/16/06
Bill (you will be assimilated) Gates forgets... BitTwiddler   | 03/16/06
This program is just the type of thing that topples Microsoft zmud   | 03/16/06
Probably won't topple Chad_z   | 03/16/06
Your tiresome paradigm ought to be toppled bill@...   | 03/16/06
Ah yes someone else that doesn't get it... Linux User 147560   | 03/16/06
Of course he has to make fun of it. He has to justify the high price for DonnieBoy   | 03/16/06
bla bla bla specialk_z   | 03/16/06
Oooo, nice one!!! NonZealot   | 03/16/06
Are you saying Windows is not a necessity and therefore NOT overpriced??? DonnieBoy   | 03/16/06
Yes specialk_z   | 03/16/06
No No No quantumstate   | 03/16/06
Re: "Of course he has to......." Scrat   | 03/16/06
The hardware requirements for Vista make it un-usable for low cost PCs. DonnieBoy   | 03/16/06
At the end of the day, Gates is right Prognosticator   | 03/16/06
At the end of the day, Gates is wrong. Cheap computers are important here DonnieBoy   | 03/16/06
Every desktop, not every hut bpick_z   | 03/16/06
Cheap computers don't hurt windows.... rock06r   | 03/16/06
Cheap computers do hurt Windows... thunderdome1   | 03/17/06
Cheap computer DON'T hurt Windows. Narg   | 03/20/06
underdeveloped?? Scott W   | 03/17/06
There are many programs out there zmud   | 03/16/06
Education quantumstate   | 03/16/06
???? chuckleberry   | 03/16/06
Gates hates third world, wants business as usual maxsnorkel   | 03/16/06
Sour grapes, Bill? techboy_z   | 03/16/06
exactly. Arm A. Geddon   | 03/16/06
They could easily run windows fat $100/unit ajole   | 03/16/06
Alrightythen SarcasticB   | 03/16/06
maybe so zmud   | 03/16/06
Is it really the best way? SarcasticB   | 03/16/06
I hope this is a lasting effort zmud   | 03/16/06
I agree SarcasticB   | 03/16/06
Freeware is free, no added costs ajole   | 03/16/06
Open source... Linux Linux User 147560   | 03/16/06
software. clockmendergb@...   | 03/16/06
Food for a family for months jivanmanchhe   | 03/16/06
I agree about the corrupt government thing zmud   | 03/16/06
Still be alive anyway... ajole   | 03/16/06
and the tumbleweed passes by Scott W   | 03/17/06
EULA reform LittleGuy   | 03/16/06
C64 modem thunderdome1   | 03/17/06
China also produced $100 computer FADS_z   | 03/16/06
Yes they're called Thinkpads sbclied   | 03/16/06
Huh? thunderdome1   | 03/17/06
$100 computer epgomez@...   | 03/18/06
let's focus on the point solutions_z   | 03/16/06
Of course Bill Gates has never zmud   | 03/16/06
Is this a joke? EJHonda   | 03/16/06
His statement was so wrong zmud   | 03/16/06
Googles not so hidden agenda! bka1959   | 03/16/06
It's nice to change the face of evil every now and then metavurt   | 03/16/06
Welcome to the real world bigpicture   | 03/16/06
a new Vista for the city-dumpster dwellers michael_t   | 03/16/06
Gates mocks MIT's $100 laptop effort aaggarwal   | 03/16/06
gates can't see past windows Scott W   | 03/17/06
Sooner or later the MAC OS will work on all pcs. jjon2121   | 03/16/06
Not on the $100 laptop, it won't! ajole   | 03/16/06
I am right on subject! jjon2121   | 03/16/06
Yeah right a laptop will teach someone to fish mrjonno   | 03/16/06
Ah but take countries like India and China perhaps even Brazil. Laff   | 03/16/06
Net cafes in every corner or 3rd wold countries sbclied   | 03/16/06
Not true for everyone....... Laff   | 03/17/06
Clueless gafisher@...   | 03/16/06
Yes, but will they? metajohn@...   | 03/17/06
So make them contented rather than discontented.... Laff   | 03/17/06
Generalization stanaland   | 03/16/06
Yeah, what all these guys above me said! ajole   | 03/16/06
more ignorance Scott W   | 03/17/06
128K RAM anyone? yyuko@...   | 03/16/06
Internet too thunderdome1   | 03/17/06
I think what he meant was pkrdk   | 03/18/06
gates and MIT Shelendrea   | 03/16/06
Oh, please read the posts about the 3rd world ajole   | 03/16/06
Then please read mine Shelendrea   | 03/17/06
doesn't change Scott W   | 03/17/06
Gates mocks MIT laptop --- Biz as usual eddie.jones@...   | 03/16/06
Demonized like Carnegie, Rockefeller, etc? ajole   | 03/16/06
Bill, is that you? 3Dman   | 03/17/06
Nope, just his tax advisor ajole   | 03/17/06
In your world... Linux User 147560   | 03/20/06
You need to get out more Bill Langalibalene   | 03/16/06
perhaps you do TonyMcS   | 03/16/06
Is he paying you something to post? 3Dman   | 03/17/06
Microsoft Government? bpick_z   | 03/16/06
View from the ground calvinolsen   | 03/16/06
Evaluate empirically, not verbally archetuthus   | 03/16/06
Bill is doing this already...sort of ajole   | 03/16/06
KISS mjd420nova   | 03/16/06
Comment from MIT Student stanaland   | 03/16/06
Does MIT really know best??? Allstar_z   | 03/16/06
You're kidding, right? techboy_z   | 03/20/06
Computers used for education thunderdome1   | 03/20/06
Previous wrong Gate's predictions pete1978   | 03/16/06
640K barrier wasn't Gates doing -- IBM dsigned the PC! metajohn@...   | 03/17/06
internet Scott W   | 03/17/06
Can they EAT the laptop ... darkstr   | 03/16/06
It too MIT to figure this out... bpick_z   | 03/16/06
You're an idiot thunderdome1   | 03/17/06
Do i know this tone ? peleshop   | 03/17/06
ITA... techboy_z   | 03/20/06
Gates Pans Low Cost PC bill@...   | 03/16/06
As long as our income is this high, no way. ajole   | 03/16/06
average income high? Shelendrea   | 03/16/06
OK, we all Complain, but most pay anyway ajole   | 03/16/06
Macs and Linux thunderdome1   | 03/17/06
It would seem like... thetargos   | 03/16/06
Hey wait a minute my webtv2 has no disk Dilberter   | 03/16/06
pot, meet kettle. glocks out   | 03/16/06
Bill is wrong, but he is living in an MS World... ajole   | 03/16/06
No disk? No software? No chance! gafisher@...   | 03/16/06
dsl ftw Scott W   | 03/17/06
And by the way webtv2 Dilberter   | 03/16/06
Hmmmmm. Kid Icarus   | 03/16/06
Another Computer-Drop Project from MIT systemBuilder_z   | 03/16/06
So make Plato work on their hardware ajole   | 03/16/06
Educational software available thunderdome1   | 03/17/06
*cough* damn small linux *cough* Scott W   | 03/17/06
Jungle huts aren't the target! ajole   | 03/16/06
I'm glad you said that whieber   | 03/16/06
Man, you said it right. 3Dman   | 03/17/06
Gee, what a surprise that Gates condemns competition critic-at-arms   | 03/16/06
...Gates, the guy who pooh-pooh'd the I'net. It figures. gunnarnc@...   | 03/16/06
Hmmmm.... jonoakley   | 03/16/06
Donations aside ballscrew bob   | 03/16/06
$100 Laptop KorVet_z   | 03/16/06
How is it a scam? thunderdome1   | 03/17/06
Is this a Bill Bashing site karl@...   | 03/16/06
Not the same purpose thunderdome1   | 03/17/06
You are a fool. 3Dman   | 03/17/06
Students dr Ladd   | 03/16/06
Gates right & $100 TOO expensive... Allstar_z   | 03/16/06
Put your money where your mouth is TonyMcS   | 03/16/06
It's a free country thunderdome1   | 03/17/06
$100 laptop Bobby Joe Reed   | 03/16/06
Why MIT is right and why Gates doesn't like it WiredGuy   | 03/16/06
Get the facts pkr@...   | 03/17/06
Huh? widge_z   | 03/17/06
You said it. 3Dman   | 03/17/06
Answers thunderdome1   | 03/17/06
correction Scott W   | 03/18/06
Not really a correction thunderdome1   | 03/20/06
free Scott W   | 03/18/06
Bill's confusing consumers with the rest of the world 3dguru   | 03/26/06
Heard of Ebay? TonyMcS   | 03/16/06
You've almost completely missed the point. 3Dman   | 03/17/06
Missing the point thunderdome1   | 03/17/06
An insult to 3rd world people sbclied   | 03/16/06
You're out of touch thunderdome1   | 03/17/06
How Helpful of Him Empress of Imaging   | 03/16/06
Get the facts pkr@...   | 03/17/06
Gates is threatened by the little guy. 3Dman   | 03/17/06
Cheap PC for Africa vger_z   | 03/17/06
No evidence of mocking deepee912   | 03/17/06
PC Mag revues the $159 PC georgep_z   | 03/17/06
Gates is SO out of touch . . . 999ad@...   | 03/17/06
What about an XBOX for poor countreis. PaulWallen   | 03/17/06
What use is an Xbox? thunderdome1   | 03/17/06
Xbox can run games and linux OS both dhagey   | 03/17/06
Still no use thunderdome1   | 03/20/06
the 100 dollar laptop and what people need dilema.. Monkey_MCSE   | 03/17/06
Of course, it doesn't run Microsoft products. dhagey   | 03/17/06
Being open-minded... Anti_Zealot   | 03/20/06
Too much polarization, lets hear alternatives chrismar   | 03/17/06
How disappointing... <sigh> :( Oxmyx   | 03/17/06
Disappointing? Try Delusional- You that is crescentdave   | 03/19/06
Yes the same man Linux User 147560   | 03/20/06
Money, money, money macaso   | 03/17/06
bill needs a reminder... wondergran   | 03/18/06
one laptop per child attywhalen@...   | 03/18/06
$199 Lap Top Efort lvincent45   | 03/18/06
MS sets sights on IBM Fred Fredrickson   | 03/20/06
Let's respond to the G-Man's quotes! HypnoToad   | 03/20/06
I'll bet zclayton2   | 03/20/06
Doesn't matter, asteriod to terminate us all Boot_Agnostic   | 03/20/06
Take a step back... nickrapak   | 03/20/06
no market share blues shraven   | 03/29/06

What do you think?