On TechRepublic: Five super-secret features in Windows 7
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

By Stephen Shankland
Posted on ZDNet News: Feb 6, 2004 5:05:00 AM

SCO Group has significantly widened its Unix and Linux lawsuit against IBM, adding a copyright infringement claim to the already complicated case, sources said Thursday.

The Lindon, Utah-based company amended its claims against IBM on the eve of a hearing about what information Big Blue needs to disclose to SCO, one of numerous steps along the path to a scheduled trial date of April 11, 2005.


Get Up to Speed on...
Open source
Get the latest headlines and
company-specific news in our
expanded GUTS section.


Copyright infringement is a major new element to SCO's current accusations that IBM breached its contract with SCO and misappropriated trade secrets by moving technology developed for proprietary Unix to open-source Linux. The case has injected some uncertainty into a computing industry that for the most part has eagerly embraced Linux, but analysts such as IDC say the suit doesn't appear to have slowed the operating system's growth.

SCO spokesman Blake Stowell declined to comment on the expanded legal attack--the company's second amended complaint against IBM--other than to say SCO plans a news announcement after Friday's hearing.

However, in a Dec. 5, 2003, hearing, SCO attorneys said the company planned to add a copyright infringement claim. And in a Wednesday filing with the court, SCO attorneys sought permission to amend their current charges against IBM.

In the motion requesting permission to amend the complaint, SCO said it might well amend its claims again once it begins receiving new information from IBM, a pipeline that Magistrate Judge Brooke Wells shut off at the December hearing.

"It is anticipated that IBM may reveal through discovery additional evidence relevant to the issues raised by its counterclaim and that SCO may in fact request future opportunity to align its claims once IBM's (sic) resumes the process of complying with its discovery obligations," SCO's attorneys said in the motion.

Wells decreed at the December hearing that SCO should meet IBM's information requests but issued a stay until Friday on IBM complying with SCO's information requests. Friday's hearing will address the issue of what information IBM should provide.

In SCO's first amended filing in June, the company increased the damages it's seeking from IBM to $3 billion, a sizable step up from the $1 billion it sought in the first claim, which was filed in March.

IBM denies wrongdoing. Its countersuit accuses SCO of violating four IBM patents.

SCO, which licensed Unix to IBM, Sun Microsystems, Hewlett-Packard, Silicon Graphics and others, argues it owns the copyright to the operating system. However, Novell, which owned Unix before selling it to SCO's predecessor in 1995, argues that it still owns the copyright.

SCO sued Novell in January over these copyright claims. The stakes of the tug-of-war between Novell and SCO have increased with Novell's January acquisition of SuSE Linux, the No. 2 Linux seller after Red Hat.

SCO, meanwhile, has said the copyright claims will be involved in a lawsuit it plans against at least one large-scale Linux user.

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 57 Talkback(s)
SCO now requesting to base case on nothing at all
It gets worse....

Now that SCO has said there are no trade secrets in SysV and have abandoned that claim they are saying the IBM is violating their copyright by contunuing to distribute AIX. B... (Read the rest)
Posted by: Still Lynn Posted on: 02/09/04 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
SCO is in the right  Christian_<>< | 02/05/04
SCO has the right  stephen732@... | 02/05/04
Don't think so but would be great.  zd-spam | 02/06/04
OOPS!  zd-spam | 02/06/04
It's up to the judge  dscherf | 02/06/04
RE: It's up to the judge  jafucci@... | 02/08/04
SCO hasn't established ANYTHING!  Eggs Ackley_z | 02/06/04
SCO is in the right?  guido_z | 02/06/04
Now there's a big if....  NemesisNL | 02/06/04
They distributed that code  azurensis | 02/06/04
SCO in the Right?  nucrash | 02/06/04
SCO is in the RIght?  jkevinm | 02/06/04
keyword = IF  blahblahblah | 02/06/04
Yes, but...  cybervegan | 02/06/04
SCO claims are dubious at best.  kimalanus | 02/06/04
Try to pick headlines that make sense w/ the message  mlybbert | 02/06/04
It will be interesting to see the result of the hearing later today (NT)  Daisy Fontana | 02/05/04
Rough transcript available on groklaw *NOW*  cybervegan | 02/06/04
Novel holds the cards -- not SCO  sbj | 02/05/04
Novell  guido_z | 02/06/04
who cares about SCO  NemesisNL | 02/06/04
SCO licensed what to whom?  csk_1975 | 02/05/04
SCO reminds me of when my kids "were kids"  ST0RMCHASER | 02/05/04
This is the IBM suit...  Fred Fredrickson | 02/06/04
If the judge has even a shred of intelligence...  NemesisNL | 02/06/04
TFA is wrong  rgriffith64@... | 02/06/04
This is the IBM suit...  Fred Fredrickson | 02/06/04
Buy SCO Stock!  jkantor | 02/06/04
buy...buy....  guido_z | 02/06/04
I think this company's actually going off the rails, you know?  DanIelWalker_z | 02/06/04
yeah...  princessangry | 02/06/04
Has SCO ever...  rmkjr@... | 02/06/04
paraniod dillusions my dear....  princessangry | 02/06/04
Am I dreaming?  NemesisNL | 02/06/04
suicide  guido_z | 02/06/04
reply for sco's going of the rails...  guido_z | 02/06/04
Wouldn't shed any? I think I might...  DanIelWalker_z | 02/06/04
This is part of Microsoft's......  Rick_K | 02/06/04
flat earth society  guido_z | 02/06/04
For a nice story about getting the facts  Fred Flintsone | 02/06/04
oh....  guido_z | 02/06/04
"Linsux advocates will say anything..." da-de-da-de-da  DanIelWalker_z | 02/06/04
Did you read the article?  IT_User | 02/06/04
tired....  princessangry | 02/06/04
Yes, Buy SCO Stock!  FlyGuy70 | 02/06/04
of course  guido_z | 02/06/04
Stolen code is the sincerest form of flattery...  LinuxDoesntCrash | 02/06/04
Why? SCO's stocks up .... that's the reason  el1jones | 02/06/04
sco right  lotta_anger | 02/06/04
Well, isn't THAT a suprise...  BitTwiddler | 02/06/04
Let's get it right here...  fullebr@... | 02/06/04
SCO now requesting to base case on nothing at all  Still Lynn | 02/09/04
But will it work  Chad_z | 02/06/04
SCO to IBM: Make me an offer  ep_myers | 02/06/04
ibm settlement?  guido_z | 02/06/04
we'll sue!  jaylt2 | 02/06/04
SCO Group has significantly widened its Unix and Linux lawsuit against IBM  preadapted | 02/06/04

What do you think?

advertisement
advertisement

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

SmartPlanet

Click Here