On TV.com: Watch Jimmy Fallon's GLEE parody
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

By David Becker
Posted on ZDNet News: Feb 20, 2004 1:18:00 AM

Microsoft has expanded its legal battle against Linux seller Lindows, suing the software maker for trademark infringement in Canada.

A Microsoft representative confirmed that the suit was filed late Wednesday in the Federal Court of Canada in Ottawa.

The suit makes trademark claims similar to previous cases filed in the United States and Europe and seeks an injunction barring Lindows from doing business under that name.

The U.S. suit, filed shortly after Lindows went into business, claims the company's name infringes on Microsoft's trademark for its Windows operating system. Lindows, which sells a version of the open-source Linux operating system with an interface similar to Windows, argues the Microsoft trademark is invalid because "window" was a generic computing term at the time it was granted.

The judge hearing the U.S. cases has sided with Lindows in denying Microsoft's requests for an injunction against the company. The judge also recently ruled in Lindows' favor in declaring that the jury must consider use of the term "windows" around the time the trademark was granted. Microsoft plans to appeal that decision, further delaying the trial.


Get Up to Speed on...
Open source
Get the latest headlines and
company-specific news in our
expanded GUTS section.


Microsoft has filed similar legal actions in several European countries, where it has been more successful with injunction requests.

Lindows CEO Michael Robertson said Microsoft is expanding the case globally mainly as a punitive business tactic against a competitor. "We've been selling to Canadian customers for more than two years, and Microsoft hasn't said a word," he said. "This is just trying to pile on lawsuits to slow us down."

The Microsoft representative said Microsoft must protect its trademarks to retain them. "Microsoft's actions in Canada are only about the Lindows name," the representative said.

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 109 Talkback(s)
Microsoft has no water for the cup...
There is no real legal issue here. People should realize Microsoft is aiming it's financial guns at Lindows and using shear weight of legal suits to try in put them out of business financially.
If ... (Read the rest)
Posted by: msdead Posted on: 02/23/04 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Now this one IS interesting  IT_User | 02/19/04
Really will not effect Lindows business in Canada.  DonnieBoy | 02/19/04
Advertising is creating an image  StorageGuru | 02/20/04
Or maybe someone will expect the ethics to follow the trademark (NT)  Update victim | 02/20/04
Anything to back up your claim  RedHat9User | 02/20/04
What is the "I HATE MS" crowd?  voska | 02/20/04
i.e. most of their customers :o)  Jack-Booted EULA | 02/20/04
It's also known as the dark side of the force  George Jay | 02/20/04
Like .Net?  WhatRUTalkingAbout | 02/21/04
Excellent question  IT_User | 02/22/04
Typical M$ Hater Here  StorageGuru | 02/20/04
Is that the best you could come up with  RedHat9User | 02/20/04
I am the public  brian ansorge | 02/21/04
very common  broadway al | 02/22/04
look at "apple"  ryusen | 02/20/04
Apple Computer Corp != apple  sa_z | 02/20/04
Really for Lindows, they need to first get name recognition.  DonnieBoy | 02/20/04
windows is a generic term, as is the os itself  stephen732@... | 02/20/04
People Like Cheap  voska | 02/20/04
actually  stephen732@... | 02/20/04
Moooo-ah-ha-ha-ha-ha-ha-ha-ha-ha-ha......  Jack-Booted EULA | 02/20/04
It Seems the M$ Crowd Doesn't Want to Hear, Either  TechinMN | 02/20/04
The laws are for everyone  StorageGuru | 02/20/04
You cannot trade on a mark of a competitor  IT_User | 02/20/04
Advertising is creating an image  prrawlins | 02/20/04
Microsoft and Lindows  antiqa111@... | 02/19/04
Caps Lock off dood!  DarbyOhara | 02/21/04
What a bunch idiots at Microsoft. These are two US companies.  DonnieBoy | 02/19/04
Trademark laws vary by country  marksashton | 02/20/04
And if I'm not mistaken...  BFD | 02/20/04
Vary by country?  IT_User | 02/20/04
Yes, Microsoft could be legally and technically correct.  DonnieBoy | 02/21/04
Well you know how it is  bonafide49 | 02/23/04
Microsoft-Lindows spat heads north  Loverock Davidson | 02/19/04
Yeah, they'll probably survive  IT_User | 02/19/04
you are correct  JWatson77 | 02/19/04
Easy answer: change their name  marksashton | 02/20/04
Naw, we need Microsoft in the headlines  IT_User | 02/20/04
And Microsoft is any better?  theace18 | 02/19/04
guess what zdnet.com's running?  ctk76 | 02/20/04
We can tak lots of this kind of free publicity.  DonnieBoy | 02/20/04
(NT) To compete with Mike Cox, you should add more colorful verbiage :o)  Jack-Booted EULA | 02/20/04
awesome!  ryusen | 02/20/04
Who you kiddin  sa_z | 02/20/04
May a suggest a new name for lindows?  gdgscubapro@... | 02/20/04
No  John CarrollZDNet Moderator | 02/20/04
It's not annoying...  Chris Moller | 02/20/04
...it's stupid  StorageGuru | 02/20/04
No, it's brilliant marketing by Lindows  George Jay | 02/20/04
Actually, you're mistaken  marksashton | 02/20/04
Wrong again Ashton  NT Admin | 02/20/04
Actually I think you are wrong...  BFD | 02/20/04
You misunderstand  marksashton | 02/20/04
It gets the name out there  voska | 02/20/04
What confusion I have seen  voska | 02/20/04
It has been lost.  bhanes@... | 02/20/04
Who knows?  StorageGuru | 02/20/04
I think the trademark "Windows" is going away  el1jones | 02/20/04
I would agree it was intentional, but you must agree Windows is generic.  DonnieBoy | 02/20/04
Windows may possibly be generic - in English  marksashton | 02/20/04
Lindows has already lost.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 02/20/04
Snickers == Marathon, and not a beat is missed  jellyclock | 02/20/04
Let me guess, you're not in marketing.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 02/20/04
Let me "guess": you're not employed  Bobby Sskcat | 02/20/04
Correct, I hire people like you.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 02/20/04
So... you are not employed and you don't know how to clean a toilet either?  B.O.F.H. | 02/20/04
Uh....not really  marksashton | 02/20/04
WRONG  MarcB_z | 02/20/04
Yes, you are wrong. But that's to be expected.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 02/20/04
You're talking about a preliminary ruling in the US ONLY  marksashton | 02/20/04
and axe..  ryusen | 02/20/04
AX the fuddster!  sa_z | 02/20/04
Key words: "sound an awful lot like"  NT Admin | 02/20/04
You're clueless  marksashton | 02/20/04
Good thing you didn't write the trademark law  NT Admin | 02/20/04
You are mistaken.  marksashton | 02/20/04
What Is a Trademark or Servicemark?  NT Admin | 02/20/04
I can't resist  marksashton | 02/20/04
PS. I apologize for "clueless" comment. Ill informed is nicer  marksashton | 02/20/04
Typical of John Carroll  sa_z | 02/20/04
microsoft ill advised don't you think?  hipparchus | 02/21/04
Brazen  IT_User | 02/21/04
Generic?  WhatRUTalkingAbout | 02/21/04
This legal stuff gets annoying  jfrankcarr | 02/20/04
Canada Being Officially Bilingual...  MacCanuck | 02/20/04
Don't forget the old SCTV skit...  phorvath2110 | 02/20/04
Microsoft wouldn't care at all if they used "Fenetre" or "Lenetre"  marksashton | 02/20/04
I like to be reminded once in awhile...  Xunil_Sierutuf | 02/20/04
He just ain't that bright (or he's a liar)  KTLA | 02/20/04
Clarification  KTLA | 02/20/04
Go Microsoft !!  Prognosticator | 02/20/04
Another ignorant  beafeater | 02/20/04
Tell it to the Juice!  StorageGuru | 02/20/04
RE: Go Microsoft  jskline0@... | 02/23/04
Its all in the name  bigbearpcs2 | 02/20/04
I want to actually see someone using Lindows  Linux is the Anti-Christ of computing | 02/20/04
Rebel Rouser  beafeater | 02/21/04
You should try it  chawly | 02/23/04
microsoft SUCKS  judgesinel@... | 02/20/04
Thank you and God Bless!  beafeater | 02/21/04
Well ......  chawly | 02/23/04
Absurdity run amuck!  Uncoveror | 02/21/04
No trademarking of windows, and no name skewing with Lindows  FilledOut | 02/21/04
Message has been deleted.  linuxcad_is_a_spammer | 02/22/04
spam  Thermite | 02/22/04
The real issue  Thermite | 02/22/04
Reminds me of the plight of Walter S. Taylor Jr.  Windex Teflon | 02/22/04
What about DEC Windows?  Art_Ilano | 02/23/04
Microsoft has no water for the cup...  msdead | 02/23/04

What do you think?

SmartPlanet

Click Here