On TV.com: PSYCH Is Canceled ? Sike!
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

By Ina Fried
Posted on ZDNet News: Jul 19, 2005 6:55:00 PM

Opening a new chapter in its rivalry with Google, Microsoft on Tuesday sued the search giant and a former Microsoft executive who has been tapped by Google to run its China operations.

The suit was filed in a Washington state court against Google and Kai-Fu Lee, who until Monday was the corporate vice president of Microsoft's Interactive Services Division.

Kai-Fu Lee
Source: Microsoft
Kai-Fu Lee

Google said earlier Tuesday that Lee was joining the company and would head up a new research effort in China.

"Accepting such a position with a direct Microsoft competitor like Google violates the narrow non-competition promise Lee made when he was hired as an executive," Microsoft said in its lawsuit, which was seen by CNET News.com. "Google is fully aware of Lee's promises to Microsoft, but has chosen to ignore them, and has encouraged Lee to violate them."

In the suit, Microsoft seeks monetary damages as well as an injunction upholding the noncompete clause and other provisions of Lee's contract, including terms barring him from sharing Microsoft trade secrets.

"There was no effort by Dr. Lee or Google to try and work out any kind of agreement."
--Tom Burt, deputy general counsel, Microsoft

Google has emerged as a top rival for Microsoft, and several notable employees have left the software giant for Google in recent months. The company is seen as an aggressive rival to Microsoft in areas such as desktop search and e-mail. In addition, its services work well with any operating system.

Google issued a press release on Lee's hiring and announced plans to open a China research and development center this quarter.

"Under the leadership of Dr. Lee, with his proven track record of innovation and his passion for technology and research, the Google China R&D center will enable us to develop more innovative products and technologies for millions of users in China and around the world," Alan Eustace, Google engineering vice president, said in a statement.

blog
Lee and Longhorn
Read about what Google's new hire was working on in his tenure at Microsoft.

Lee, an expert in speech recognition technology, founded Microsoft's China research lab in the late 1990s and worked at Silicon Graphics Inc. and Apple Computer before joining Microsoft.

A Google representative was not immediately available to comment on Microsoft's legal actions.

Google's public touting that it had hired Lee is in and of itself unique. The company rarely announces new hires, with CEO Eric Schmidt's hiring being a notable exception.

Though workers leave tech companies for rivals all the time, it's not uncommon for a dispute to end up in court, particularly when an executive has a contract with a noncompete clause. Microsoft has turned to legal channels before to pursue former employees who it felt were unfairly competing against the company.

Notably, the company sued when former executive Tod Nielsen and a number of ex-Microsoft employees went to work for Crossgain, a start-up that was focused on allowing business applications to run over the Web.

Crossgain eventually disassociated itself from a number of Microsoft workers that were still bound to noncompete agreements. Among the other ex-Microsofties who were forced to step down, at least temporarily, were Nielsen and Adam Bosworth, a founder of Crossgain.

Crossgain was swallowed up by BEA Systems in 2001, with both Nielsen and Bosworth joining the software maker. The two left BEA last year, and Bosworth joined Google.

A Microsoft lawyer said in an interview that Lee's move to join Google was a "particularly egregious" violation of the noncompete agreement that he had signed when he joined Microsoft.

"He has access to sensitive information, to trade secrets about our search technology and business plans and our China business strategies," Deputy General Counsel Tom Burt told CNET News.com. "He has accepted a position in direct competition with Microsoft in those areas."

Lee had been working most recently at Microsoft's Redmond, Wash., headquarters, focusing on new search technologies. According to the lawsuit, for a time Lee had been the person "responsible for overall development of the MSN Internet search application." He also served as a member of a company advisory board that focused on China-related strategies, a post that, according to the suit, gave him access to the company's business strategy and planned expansion targets.

In the suit, Microsoft said that on July 5, Lee informed his department head, Eric Rudder, that he did not plan to return to Microsoft from a sabbatical and that he had talked with Google about heading up that company's China efforts.

Burt said that Microsoft was formally notified of Lee's plans Monday and that the company served him with legal papers later that day.

"There was no effort by Dr. Lee or Google to try and work out any kind of agreement," Burt said. "The combination of those factors meant that we really had no choice but to file this suit to protect our confidential information."

CNET News.com's Stefanie Olsen contributed to this report.

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 89 Talkback(s)
Add them?
They've been at the top of that list for years. It may not be a part
of their well crafted public image, but they have a huge legal
department that they have used to sue potential competitors ... (Read the rest)
Posted by: Immanuel Tranz-Mischen Posted on: 07/21/05 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Microsoft better get used to it. Employees will be leaving in droves.  DonnieBoy | 07/19/05
They can leave all they want  Loverock Davidson | 07/19/05
Microsoft should just try to compete instead of crying about one employee  DonnieBoy | 07/19/05
They do compete  Loverock Davidson | 07/19/05
Microsoft, trade secrets?? Are you serious??  DonnieBoy | 07/19/05
he is serious  stormdoor | 07/20/05
If you work for MS...  John L. Ries | 07/19/05
Tricky indeed  Loverock Davidson | 07/19/05
Good reason not to work for MS (NT)  John L. Ries | 07/19/05
There are time limits on those non compete contracts  osreinstall | 07/19/05
Most I've seen are 2 and 3 years  voska | 07/20/05
That is for the average worker  osreinstall | 07/20/05
That's the tricky part  voska | 07/19/05
Not down here Voska  osreinstall | 07/19/05
Actually it depends on where  voska | 07/20/05
Listen Microfanboy...  Colonel_Panic | 07/19/05
infantile comments....  critique | 07/20/05
Bah! I don't like google either...  Colonel_Panic | 07/20/05
DonnieBoy, are you clueless...  John Zern | 07/19/05
Most non-compete agreements are NOT enforcable. Only to scare employees.  DonnieBoy | 07/19/05
what planet do you live on?  No_Ax_to_Grind | 07/19/05
Sure thing, Don  Yagotta B. Kidding | 07/19/05
Last time I checked, slave labor is NOT legal.  DonnieBoy | 07/19/05
Be careful if you do contract work though  voska | 07/19/05
Not just contractors  A.Sinic | 07/20/05
Slave labor?  Real World | 07/20/05
Slavery  A.Sinic | 07/20/05
All consultants (even dependent) work like that  FirstNLastN | 07/19/05
They've been defeated in court too  voska | 07/19/05
Maybe in the USA they are  FirstNLastN | 07/19/05
Look at how many people get convicted  voska | 07/19/05
ALL contracts are enforcable, beware what you sign...  Physco Dude | 07/20/05
By your definition Zern...  nomorems | 07/19/05
Really, looks to me like Google needed him.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 07/19/05
Every company needs good employees  Jeff Spicoli | 07/19/05
More important, the best and brightest do NOT want to work for MS anymore.  DonnieBoy | 07/19/05
You are full of crap.  osreinstall | 07/19/05
Now you hit some things enforcable, the GPL and your house mortgage.  DonnieBoy | 07/19/05
You are Wrong  osreinstall | 07/19/05
Judges can throw out contracts that are ilegal.  DonnieBoy | 07/19/05
I am sure MS's contracts are legal  osreinstall | 07/19/05
I have experience with this  voska | 07/20/05
There are contracts and there are contracts!  osreinstall | 07/20/05
Judges can throw out contracts that are ilegal.  doc_cotton | 07/20/05
No wonder they can't find employees  nucrash | 07/19/05
Yes, the fact they are suing ex-employees is just one more reason to avoid  DonnieBoy | 07/19/05
Message for DonnieBoy  B.Beck | 07/19/05
Still a good reason not work for MS  voska | 07/19/05
Sadly...  Immanuel Tranz-Mischen | 07/20/05
Nope  nomorems | 07/19/05
Well, we do like bashing Microsoft, they do so many stupid things.  DonnieBoy | 07/19/05
He didn't sign the clause.  Immanuel Tranz-Mischen | 07/20/05
Microsoft sues over Google hire  Loverock Davidson | 07/19/05
Something about color, pots, and kettles  Robert Crocker | 07/19/05
A contract is a contract.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 07/19/05
Microsoft breaks contracts for breakfast  Jeff Spicoli | 07/19/05
Depends on the contract  voska | 07/19/05
Depends how legal the contract is  voska | 07/19/05
That's what I thought..  Patrick Jones | 07/19/05
It usually does take courts  voska | 07/20/05
Why care?  nomorems | 07/19/05
Re: A contract is a contract.  none none | 07/19/05
Right..  Patrick Jones | 07/19/05
Google didn't sign a contract  Michael Kelly | 07/19/05
booyah  Jeff Spicoli | 07/19/05
Because  Real World | 07/20/05
Here is why.  osreinstall | 07/20/05
Well, Microsoft's reputation is ruined already.  Immanuel Tranz-Mischen | 07/20/05
Fairness  yyuko@... | 07/19/05
Gotta be kiddinG!  Reverend MacFellow | 07/19/05
Lee is now a PR more than a aggressive researcher  ChinesePhDinCA | 07/20/05
Microsoft's Trade Secrets ?!??!!  daver10 | 07/20/05
Well, well....  Anti_Zealot | 07/20/05
Add them?  Immanuel Tranz-Mischen | 07/21/05
Microsoft, the masters of IP theft  whisperycat | 07/20/05
Goes back even further to Stacker, Quarterdeck...  ordaj@... | 07/20/05
What Are You Talking About? Microsoft Is Leader In Innovation!!!  itanalyst | 07/20/05
Maybe now  Roger Ramjet | 07/20/05
Good ol' STUPID Microsoft.  SmarterITGuy | 07/20/05
Kai Fu Lee Was Great In "Chips Of Fury"  itanalyst | 07/20/05
Working in specialized fields  xkmail | 07/20/05
Direct Competitor?? i don't see google selling computer operating systems  wessonjoe | 07/20/05
If you DARE to leave, we are gonna get you... (Why MS, Why?)  michael_t | 07/20/05
Microsoft sues over Google hire  doc_cotton | 07/20/05
Who To Hate More Google or Microsoft.  RobertoSalazar | 07/20/05
That's easy: Microsoft  Immanuel Tranz-Mischen | 07/20/05
Lotsa luck  code_flogger | 07/20/05
Stay on focus!  osreinstall | 07/20/05
I think you mean, "a history of limited success."  Immanuel Tranz-Mischen | 07/20/05

What do you think?

advertisement

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

SmartPlanet

Click Here