On mySimon: You Can Have It All
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

By Graeme Wearden
Posted on ZDNet News: Feb 22, 2006 3:22:00 PM

The long-running legal battle over claims that IBM's contribution to Linux violates SCO Group's intellectual property took another twist on Tuesday when IBM sent subpoenas to four other tech players.

Microsoft, Hewlett-Packard, Sun Microsystems and BayStar Capital must hand over details of their involvement with SCO, according to the subpoenas, which were filed in U.S. District Court in Utah, where the case between IBM and SCO is being heard.

IBM, meanwhile, is building its defenses against the charge that it included SCO's Unix code in its contribution to Linux.

The subpoenas demand that Microsoft, HP, Sun and BayStar hand over a range of information, including details of their dealings with SCO, by March 7. They will also have to appear in court later in March to give depositions.

Groklaw, a legal Web site that had been following the case closely, believes that the subpoenas could help bring important information about the case to light.

"I begin to think that every question we've had, we will finally get to know the answer," wrote Groklaw's Pamela Jones, who published the subpoenas on the Groklaw site.

Back in March 2003, SCO filed a lawsuit alleging that IBM had included code from Unix in its contribution to Linux, which SCO claimed was a violation of its intellectual property. However, Novell then claimed that it, rather than SCO, owned the copyright on Unix, which prompted another lawsuit from SCO. In August 2003, IBM countersued SCO.

The subpoenas filed on Tuesday are part of the discovery phase of the case, during which IBM can gather evidence in its defense.

Microsoft's subpoena runs to 13 separate demands. They include handing over details of agreements relating to any Unix product involving Microsoft and SCO, and all communications between the two companies. In early 2003, Microsoft started paying SCO what eventually grew to $16.6 million for a Unix license, according to regulatory filings. Only longtime Unix fan Sun previously paid close to that, with a $9.3 million license deal. Microsoft provided a second, though indirect, boost in August or September of 2003, when it referred SCO to BayStar, a fund that arranged a $50 million investment.

Sun itself must reveal details of any agreements or licenses between it and SCO for the Unix source code, any documents referring to the open-sourcing of any of its Unix products, as well as Sun's involvement in the development of Linux.

HP has been ordered to give the court details of "agreements relating to any Unix software product involving HP and AT&T, USL (Unix System Laboratories), Novell, Santa Cruz (Operation) and SCO," as well as details of any royalties HP pays for Unix and the origin of any Unix source code publicly disclosed or open-sourced by HP.

It also forces HP to disclose any communications it has had with SCO since June 28, 2002.

BayStar must hand over details of its communications, agreements and investments in SCO. It must also reveal communications between it and Microsoft regarding SCO, IBM and the ongoing court case.

After its October 2003 investment, BayStar began attempting to force changes at SCO.

Graeme Wearden of ZDNet UK reported from London.

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 76 Talkback(s)
URL truncated, but ...
... SUN has already done as much for The SCO Group as they can. Anyone buying tSCOG now will be buying their liabilities which amount to billions owed to IBM, RedHat and Novell.

Even when the ... (Read the rest)
Posted by: Still Lynn Posted on: 02/24/06 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Who's Pauline Jones?(nt)  #_z | 02/22/06
And in other news  I'm Ye, the MS SHILL . | 02/22/06
It like Ashcroft never left the Bush Administration  mighetto | 02/22/06
Message has been deleted.  specialk_z | 02/22/06
Then undelete it dillweeds  specialk_z | 02/22/06
RTFA  Yagotta B. Kidding | 02/22/06
It's been corrected now  #_z | 02/22/06
I A N A L - read the message before you delete it you f-in morons  specialk_z | 02/22/06
For job  fatihuz50 | 02/23/06
Has SCO actually proven anything yet?  doctormoriarty | 02/22/06
That would ruin everything!  Still Lynn | 02/22/06
re That would ruin everything!  mdsmedia | 02/22/06
the criminal M$ will be exposed  Linux Geek | 02/22/06
And in other news .  I'm Ye, the MS SHILL . | 02/22/06
IBM does not have a version of Linux  blhseawa | 02/22/06
Where have you been lately ?  I'm Ye, the MS SHILL . | 02/22/06
IBM March Linux in Seattle  mighetto | 02/22/06
You should have went  Still Lynn | 02/22/06
Distribution of OS w/Hardware doesn't mean anything  dhagey | 02/22/06
Linux code contributions  DNSB | 02/22/06
Yes, SCOX claims control over drivers for IBM hardware  Still Lynn | 02/23/06
Missing background info  Still Lynn | 02/23/06
IBM does sell various distros of Linux  drichards1953 | 02/22/06
DYNIX NUMA use leaked to AIX and LINUX  eddoaloha | 02/23/06
IBM used consultants to lift SCO UNIX to AIX   | 02/23/06
Assembling astroturf into IP turf?  Still Lynn | 02/23/06
Lynn, Lynn ... the pieces are in the resume history & pilot's log   | 02/23/06
I'm sure you're as much a lady as I am, so ...  Still Lynn | 02/24/06
Watch out for that tree!  Still Lynn | 02/24/06
IBM issues subpoenas for tech giants' SCO dealings  Loverock Davidson | 02/22/06
When Microsoft Complies!!!!!  nucrash | 02/22/06
Slashdot called  Loverock Davidson | 02/22/06
We'll gladly let Slashdot have you back  barsteward | 02/22/06
Have me back?  Loverock Davidson | 02/22/06
No Kidding.  nucrash | 02/22/06
Don't get mad  Loverock Davidson | 02/22/06
I am sorry, I was wrong.  nucrash | 02/22/06
So when do you leave...  Physco Dude | 02/23/06
"Her site is baseless and biased."  mdsmedia | 02/22/06
Unlike your nice and wise comments which can not be confused by facts -(NT)  Update victim | 02/22/06
those with a brain  Network Support | 02/23/06
Hopefully all of this will end soon  Boot_Agnostic | 02/22/06
Duplicate key or integrity constraint violation, message from server: "Dupl  No_Ax_to_Grind | 02/22/06
best response yet (n/t)  specialk_z | 02/22/06
Yeah, what IS that all about, Axey?  Judas I. | 02/22/06
Yes, another wonderful Zdnet Talkback upgrade probably  Boot_Agnostic | 02/22/06
The bottom line is that 100s of millions $$$ is wasted on  michael_t | 02/22/06
Assume Microsoft is Paying  mighetto | 02/22/06
Interesting timing  Chad_z | 02/22/06
unable to blog to article  defconvegas | 02/22/06
Not Sissies, Microsoft is the Master of Legals  mighetto | 02/22/06
Yes  Boot_Agnostic | 02/22/06
OK..  nomorems | 02/22/06
Praise, if only I directed the paragraph that way  Boot_Agnostic | 02/22/06
MS deserves no praise  georgep_z | 02/22/06
That's true  sykandtyed | 02/22/06
Duplicate key or integrity constraint violation, message from server: "Dupl  defconvegas | 02/22/06
When is open source not?  stevem_001 | 02/22/06
THIS BLOODY ZD NET IS SPAMMING ME  fakir005@... | 02/22/06
Welcome  D. T. Schmitz | 02/22/06
IBM IS TROUBLE MAKER  fakir005@... | 02/22/06
"Open Source" does not mean "no-one owns it"  mdsmedia | 02/22/06
what era are you in?  dhagey | 02/22/06
Huh  Gregory.J.Bradley@... | 02/22/06
Yawn....  DNSB | 02/22/06
PEBKAC  thunderdome1 | 02/23/06
SCO is a poor looser, sorry player  basilf@... | 02/22/06
SCO Has Nothing IBM Wants  Edward Meyers | 02/23/06
IBM cleaned SCO out using consultants & contractors   | 02/23/06
okay, put up or .......  wrench_ninja | 02/23/06
To Bad The Current SCO is Caldera and May Own Squat  Edward Meyers | 02/23/06
Premature Brain Death  Still Lynn | 02/23/06
No they didn't  cotech@... | 02/23/06
Follow the money...  Mr. Roboto | 02/23/06
Could Sun hold a key to SCO's future?  AldoWatts | 02/24/06
URL truncated, but ...  Still Lynn | 02/24/06

What do you think?

advertisement
advertisement

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Meet Doc

  • Here to help you with your Document Management Needs
  • Doc is an enigma. Born to a Russian ballerina and a German electrical engineer, he grew up in various locations in the United States. He’s seen the insides of more brands, versions, and generations of printer and printer-related hardware than almost anyone.
  • To learn more about this mysterious figure check out his blog on ZDNet and his Workspace on TechRepublic. You’ll be glad you did.
  • Produced by
    ZDNet and