On BNET: Online porn struggles for profits
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

By Michael Kanellos
Posted on ZDNet News: Dec 7, 2004 7:28:00 PM

SAN FRANCISCO--A deal that would let China's Lenovo acquire IBM's PC unit would work about as well as other mergers in the industry, Michael Dell said--that is, not well.

During a question-and-answer session Tuesday at Oracle's OpenWorld conference, the Dell chairman said a deal between Lenovo and IBM would likely follow a pattern seen in many mergers where two very different organizations fail to mesh.

"We're not big fans of the idea of taking companies and smashing them together," Dell said. "When was the last time you saw a successful acquisition or merger in the computer industry? It hasn't happened in a long, long time...I don't see this one as being all that different."

Dell also said his company is not interested in buying IBM's PC unit. Dell has only made a few acquisitions in its 20-year history. They have all been relatively small. The company's largest and first acquisition, ConvergeNet, helped get Dell into the storage market, but it didn't work out, and Dell dissolved the unit a few months later.

"We like to acquire our customers one customer at a time. We see organic growth as the more sustainable and healthy way," he said.

When asked how a deal would affect the Round Rock, Texas, computer maker, Dell was oblique but said the deal is part of a longer trend at IBM to move out of technology that's not part of back-end computer systems. By contrast, manufacturing is one of Dell's chief strengths.

"If you look over the last few years, there has been a continuing trend of not only declines in market share but de-emphasis and divestiture of various assets of the small computer system business at IBM. It's pretty clear this is not the long-term strategic priority for IBM," he said. "In our case, it's a different story. Last week, in stark contrast, we announced a brand-new computer manufacturing plant in North Carolina to support our growth in the U.S."

In recent years, Dell has also been gaining market share in China, a trend that has prompted Lenovo to cut prices. SAN FRANCISCO--A deal that would let China's Lenovo acquire IBM's PC unit would work about as well as other mergers in the industry, Michael Dell said--that is, not well.

During a question-and-answer session Tuesday at Oracle's OpenWorld conference, the Dell chairman said a deal between Lenovo and IBM would likely follow a pattern seen in many mergers where two very different organizations fail to mesh.

"We're not big fans of the idea of taking companies and smashing them together," Dell said. "When was the last time you saw a successful acquisition or merger in the computer industry? It hasn't happened in a long, long time...I don't see this one as being all that different."

Dell also said his company is not interested in buying IBM's PC unit. Dell has only made a few acquisitions in its 20-year history. They have all been relatively small. The company's largest and first acquisition, ConvergeNet, helped get Dell into the storage market, but it didn't work out, and Dell dissolved the unit a few months later.

"We like to acquire our customers one customer at a time. We see organic growth as the more sustainable and healthy way," he said.

When asked how a deal would affect the Round Rock, Texas, computer maker, Dell was oblique but said the deal is part of a longer trend at IBM to move out of technology that's not part of back-end computer systems. By contrast, manufacturing is one of Dell's chief strengths.

"If you look over the last few years, there has been a continuing trend of not only declines in market share but de-emphasis and divestiture of various assets of the small computer system business at IBM. It's pretty clear this is not the long-term strategic priority for IBM," he said. "In our case, it's a different story. Last week, in stark contrast, we announced a brand-new computer manufacturing plant in North Carolina to support our growth in the U.S."

In recent years, Dell has also been gaining market share in China, a trend that has prompted Lenovo to cut prices.

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 77 Talkback(s)
wrong
Better brand name? Which one of the failing better brand names can do this? HP couldn't do it, neither could Compaq, nor Gateway nor Toshiba remeber PackardBell (though you can buy them in UK I think)?
eMachine perhaps? Labor cost would not be enough to offset Dell volume sales.... (Read the rest)
Posted by: prong@... Posted on: 12/14/04 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Hard to argue his points.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 12/07/04
I agree, and one of the BIGGEST victims ...  Judas I. | 12/07/04
I've had a number of lappies and the ThinkPad has been the best.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 12/07/04
Wasn't ThinkPad made by a Chinese company already? (NT)  Anton Philidor | 12/07/04
Yup, to IBM's specs though.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 12/07/04
Then it would be like a Dell . . .(NT)  Ken_z | 12/07/04
Made in China != Chinese Quality  dsnyder_z | 12/08/04
It may prove hard but far from impossible  bugmenotznet | 12/08/04
It may prove hard but far from impossible  bugmenotznet | 12/08/04
Plus...  rapson | 12/08/04
Of course Mr Dell would say this, DUH!  htotten | 12/07/04
Dell gains in China?  PC Morph | 12/07/04
Chinese Market  jblood | 12/08/04
We shall see.  systemcleaner | 12/08/04
Simple...  No_Ax_to_Grind | 12/07/04
Why hire Dell?  systemcleaner | 12/07/04
Does "name" win?  jblood | 12/08/04
Hey, wake up!  systemcleaner | 12/08/04
Poor Michael Dud  Jeff Spicoli | 12/07/04
Poor? Not Hardly.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 12/07/04
Poor in VISION my friend  Jeff Spicoli | 12/07/04
Dell-bashing ... what's new ...  lalogos | 12/08/04
Then tell Mike Dell to stop bashing IBM.  systemcleaner | 12/08/04
IBM Chinese...  jblood | 12/09/04
Enough VISION to build the #1 PC company in the world.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 12/08/04
Morally bankrupt is morally bankrupt  rapson | 12/08/04
Re: Morally bankrupt is morally bankrupt  dsnyder_z | 12/08/04
Sorry  rapson | 12/08/04
Rush to judgement ...  George Mitchell | 12/07/04
I thought he was ASKED his opinion.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 12/07/04
HIS OPINION is that the HP/Compaq merger was a failure?  George Mitchell | 12/07/04
I think it was  John L. Ries | 12/07/04
Agreed; still waiting on HP/Compaq  Anton Philidor | 12/07/04
Businesses are not in business to create employment opportunities  George Mitchell | 12/07/04
Both wrong  John L. Ries | 12/08/04
The Unix workstation business was trashed by Intel and Linux  George Mitchell | 12/07/04
Why emphasize Unix workstations?  Anton Philidor | 12/07/04
Because that was what John L. Ries comment was referring to ...  George Mitchell | 12/07/04
Correction George!  ShadeTree | 12/08/04
Failure of commercial UNIX  John L. Ries | 12/08/04
Any any case, HP's computer base was in Unix hardware  George Mitchell | 12/08/04
Ok, opinion and spin combined.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 12/07/04
The HP merger success only for Mike and Carly  Art Royce | 12/08/04
HP Failure  jblood | 12/08/04
Dell is no 1 world wide? Where did you get this?  systemcleaner | 12/08/04
Dell IS Number 1 worldwide.  jblood | 12/09/04
Product subsidies  BK2552 | 12/09/04
You are correct my friend...  htotten | 12/09/04
Michael Dell is scared.  systemcleaner | 12/07/04
Yep  rapson | 12/08/04
Why would Dell be scared?  jblood | 12/08/04
Now they have figured how to beat Dell. Yes, now.  systemcleaner | 12/08/04
Cost  jblood | 12/09/04
wrong  prong@... | 12/14/04
And how is that?  prong@... | 12/14/04
support communist china - buy an IBM pc  wessonjoe | 12/08/04
Buy American  jblood | 12/08/04
New Marketing Hook  Elodea | 12/08/04
jeez this is the 21st century, why fight against democracy when you can fix  hipparchus2000 | 12/08/04
Explain, please?  rapson | 12/08/04
"When was the last time you saw a successful acquisition or merger..."  mbhull@... | 12/08/04
IBM Servers??  dhammond@... | 12/09/04
Communist China  Scorpion_z | 12/08/04
commie computers  comiman | 12/08/04
Successful tech mergers  John L. Ries | 12/08/04
What a merger  dougpierson@... | 12/08/04
I didn't say it was a mega-merger  John L. Ries | 12/08/04
Merging bad, outsourcing okay?  keltek | 12/08/04
IBM to China!!??  chuckleonard@... | 12/08/04
IBM- Big RED!  jblood | 12/09/04
PC Brands  pebear | 12/08/04
Michael Dell:IBM/Lenovo Deal "see the future"  mluff | 12/08/04
IBM SALE  PFULLAGA | 12/08/04
Just a dig at the real competition  neumo64 | 12/08/04
IBM deal worst of all worlds  racintazz@... | 12/09/04
IBM Sells to Lenovo in China  activist | 12/09/04
china - the new enemy  texbc2000 | 12/09/04

What do you think?

Click Here
advertisement
advertisement

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

SmartPlanet

  • Thought-provoking progressive ideas on diverse topics that intersect with technology, business, and life, and matter to the world at large. Visit SmartPlanet
  • More from IBM
  • Innovate your business' process model, play against the market, compete against others on our scoreboards and WIN! Try INNOV8 2.0: A BPM Simulator
  • Enabling Real-World Business Transformation through IBM Service Management Read the EMA Analyst Report
Click Here