On CBS.com: U2 on Letterman: All week, every day
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

By David Meyer , ZDNet (UK)
Posted on ZDNet News: Aug 24, 2007 10:35:00 AM

A Linux user who was jailed for uploading a film onto a peer-to-peer service has been told he will have to switch to Windows if he wants to use a computer again.

Scott McCausland, who used to be an administrator of the EliteTorrents BitTorrent server before it was shut down by the FBI, pleaded guilty in 2006 to two copyright-related charges over the uploading of Star Wars: Episode III to the Internet. As a result, he was sentenced to five months in jail and five months' home confinement.

McCausland--who also goes by the name "sk0t"--has since been released from jail, but on Tuesday he reported on his blog that the terms of his sentence meant he would have to install Windows if he wanted to use a computer during his probation. "I had a meeting with my probation officer today, and he told me that he has to install monitoring software onto my PC," wrote McCausland. "No big deal to me...that is part of my sentence."

"However, their software doesn't support GNU/Linux (which is what I use)," continued McCausland. "So, he told me that if I want to use a computer, I would have to use an OS that the software can be installed on. Which basically means: Microsoft and monitoring software or no computer. I use Ubuntu 7.04 now, and they are trying to force me to switch. First they give me two felonies, then they throw me in prison, and now this."

According to the Web site TorrentFreak, McCausland and his attorney will fight the situation. "It isn't the fact that I have to be monitored that bothers me, it is the fact that I have (to) restructure my life (different OS, different software on that OS) and that they would require (force) me to purchase software while I am currently unemployed and relatively unemployable with the two felonies that they gave me," McCausland said. "It is just a ridiculous situation."

David Meyer of ZDNet UK reported from London.

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 139 Talkback(s)
prime example
of our judicial system gone amok..Who wrote such guide lines & are they legal just because some DA says so...... (Read the rest)
Posted by: gdude@... Posted on: 09/01/07 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Virtualized Linux  mighetto | 08/24/07
Oh Well...  osreinstall | 08/24/07
no he should not have access to a computer  herdin | 08/28/07
Unenforceable that way.  osreinstall | 08/28/07
What a BOGUS title!  NonZealot | 08/24/07
It's still pretty stupid  voska | 08/24/07
TV is more than a privilege it is a birth right  mighetto | 08/24/07
re: It's still pretty stupid  M.R. Kennedy | 08/25/07
What Happens if he runs a L:iveCD with a USB Drive?  JLHenry | 08/29/07
What would you say...  jasonp@... | 08/24/07
Bad Analogy...  Wolfie2K3 | 08/27/07
Then maybe . . .  JLHenry | 08/29/07
He's convicted  flatliner | 08/27/07
DUI driving  A.Sinic | 08/28/07
I agree  safesax2002 | 08/31/07
One more thing...  safesax2002 | 08/31/07
Let the man have his operating system  RynUK | 08/24/07
It is business..  notme403@... | 08/24/07
Tell him...  jasonp@... | 08/24/07
I disagree  RynUK | 08/24/07
...  Khyron | 08/27/07
Missed one point  Larry the Security Guy | 08/27/07
More to the point  Freebird54 | 08/28/07
A little sympathy...  online@... | 08/27/07
ain't that trhe truth  strangefruit | 08/25/07
W0W - somebody had to say it!  not of this world | 08/25/07
ROTFL  Shelendrea | 08/24/07
If you can't afford a lawyer  voska | 08/24/07
I hear you  Shelendrea | 08/24/07
OJ, don't forget.  People | 08/24/07
And the supreme irony here:  Wolfie2K3 | 08/27/07
How did he afford one? Here's how.  Raymond Danner | 08/27/07
This guy is bass ackwards  Michael Kelly | 08/24/07
Spot on. (nt)  John E Wahd | 08/24/07
The system is bending over ackwards as well  jaybyrd | 08/24/07
Allegedly?  LinuxHippie | 08/27/07
'puter access  conspicuouschick | 08/27/07
Go back to jail  wthilo@... | 08/27/07
Workaround  davidsarmstrong | 08/27/07
Hear, hear!  gary@... | 08/28/07
It's only for 5 months, get over it  voska | 08/24/07
Virtual Windows  Boot_Agnostic | 08/24/07
Linux felon forced to install Windows  Loverock Davidson | 08/24/07
Thanks For Proving You're An IDIOT  itanalyst | 08/24/07
Long live the live cd  abdominalsnowman | 08/24/07
Don't Waste Your Breath On Him  itanalyst | 08/24/07
Re: Linux felon forced to install Windows  none none | 08/26/07
At least he was not one of those wierd BSD freaks...  B.O.F.H. | 08/26/07
Violates 8th Amendment  Grolan | 08/27/07
Window - for those who want to be watched  davidsarmstrong | 08/27/07
Dude  Shelendrea | 08/24/07
Dudette  Loverock Davidson | 08/24/07
Yeah right  Shelendrea | 08/24/07
Hmmmm  davidsarmstrong | 08/27/07
I'll give you an 8.6 . . .  JLHenry | 08/29/07
I Got Caught By The MPAA Downloading A Movie  itanalyst | 08/24/07
I wasn't caught by the MPAA Downloading a Movie  Futurdreamz@... | 08/24/07
BSD?  davidsarmstrong | 08/27/07
OS  chris1955 | 08/27/07
It's called punishment  davidsarmstrong | 08/27/07
Question  SoberDub | 08/24/07
Dual OS  abdominalsnowman | 08/24/07
FORCED  chris1955 | 08/27/07
Felonies "they gave me"  videodave@... | 08/24/07
Just don't use a computer for 5 months. It won't kill you  stevey_d | 08/24/07
With conviction comes punishment.  Jack-Booted EULA | 08/24/07
I suggest they upgrade to the latest and best punishment  stevey_d | 08/24/07
Vista - Cruel but not unusual punishment.  not of this world | 08/25/07
Only if his computer has 512MB and is a Pentium III...  HypnoToad72 | 08/26/07
Really???  pfyearwood | 08/27/07
Needs a whaaaambulance  People | 08/24/07
LOL  xxn1927 | 08/27/07
Mixed thoughts...  Cheval | 08/24/07
Talking about . . .  CobraA1 | 08/24/07
It's just part of his sentence. No sympathy here.  CobraA1 | 08/24/07
People! He uploaded a movie!!!  Logics | 08/25/07
Actually it very much does fit the crime  Michael Kelly | 08/25/07
Again, the punishment has nothing to DO with the crime.  HypnoToad72 | 08/26/07
Gimme a break  Jim from NoVA | 08/27/07
It's more than $99  davidsarmstrong | 08/27/07
It's only $99 . . .  JLHenry | 08/29/07
Only socialists use force [nt]  Omch'Ar | 08/25/07
Open the dictionary  rarsa | 08/28/07
Boohoohoo. Let's start a letter campaign....  rock06r | 08/25/07
He uploaded a moive  davidsarmstrong | 08/27/07
Awww, the little felon is all upset.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 08/26/07
lol...  jasonp@... | 08/26/07
rofl  B.O.F.H. | 08/26/07
Sorry Ax  THEE WOLF | 08/26/07
Now THAT'S irony...  Wolfie2K3 | 08/27/07
Get a clue yourself........  SirCatlord | 08/28/07
where is the first amendment here?  Linux Geek | 08/26/07
You lose those rights  Michael Kelly | 08/26/07
Normally I don't feed a troll, but...  noisecraft | 08/27/07
Show me....  Wolfie2K3 | 08/27/07
One pirate forced to pay a company that caters to other pirates?!  HypnoToad72 | 08/26/07
It's a conspiracy!  THEE WOLF | 08/26/07
Linux is a billion dollar business  davidsarmstrong | 08/27/07
In the end  Boot_Agnostic | 08/27/07
Linux felon...  rondev | 08/27/07
whos in bed with who  goose5843 | 08/27/07
Mac  chris1955 | 08/27/07
Cruel and Unusual Punishment! ROFLOL!  RRobert03 | 08/27/07
cost  chris1955 | 08/27/07
At least some users pay their own costs  kenneth.kelley@... | 08/27/07
if you can't pay the fine then don't do the crime  eric__m | 08/27/07
killing is fine, just don't steal from corp america  anthony.a.wilson@... | 08/27/07
LOL loopholes hello, the government isnt to smart!  masterxtds | 08/27/07
get the pickpocket while the hackers get away  masterxtds | 08/27/07
What???? Looks like the RIAA got ahold of this thread  pcguy777 | 08/27/07
The System Has Failed...  victorsebastian | 08/27/07
Holy Cow!  QAonCall | 08/27/07
Wierd but true story  kokuryu | 08/27/07
So it's official. Windows is a punishment.  Dr.C | 08/27/07
Somehow - he really doesn't get it..  done@... | 08/27/07
You beat me to it  KØRC | 08/27/07
http://ct.zdnet.com/clicks?t=39804809-93fcf3a16d70e12cbed278ece5815dd8-bf&s  moodiesburn | 08/27/07
right  Jim from NoVA | 08/27/07
If you live  jason.mailley | 08/27/07
If ur gonna do the deed, ur gonna hafta do the time...suck it up  Jim from NoVA | 08/27/07
don't reboot  muddy_13@... | 08/27/07
Felom forced to use windows  bfilipiak@... | 08/27/07
Come on people  roaming | 08/27/07
Cruel and Unusual Punishment  jknits | 08/27/07
Nobody "Gave" him 2 felonies  TranMan | 08/27/07
If he's so intent...  jjohnson.now@... | 08/27/07
Geez, life can be a real _itch sometimes!!  netone123 | 08/27/07
Awww Poor Baby  Sickthing | 08/27/07
it's like Baretta used to say Bubba;  pete_w_flynn@... | 08/28/07
Stars Wars: Episode III?!  theuns@... | 08/28/07
Is this a sign of the times...  armith@... | 08/28/07
Cruel and unusual Punishment  High Sierra | 08/28/07
NEED REAL PUNISHMENT??  jlgjrh@... | 08/28/07
i guess.....  crazy_1 | 08/28/07
Get over it!  Dr. John | 08/28/07
More goverment control over people.  SirCatlord | 08/28/07
Putting his time to good use!  theuns@... | 08/29/07
Court Violation of civil rights  ITSa341@... | 08/30/07
prime example  gdude@... | 09/01/07

What do you think?

advertisement
advertisement

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Introducing SmartPlanet

  • Find thought-provoking progressive ideas on topics that intersect with technology, business and life. Visit Today
  • Technology, perspective, and insights shaping the world
  • Learn innovative and practical skills for your business and your life. SmartPlanet offers 360 degree coverage that you need to feel connected to the information that matters to the world at large. Go to SmartPlanet
advertisement
Click Here