On CNET: CNET TV now in HD!
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

By Alorie Gilbert, News.com
Posted on ZDNet News: Jan 29, 2005 2:24:00 AM

Microsoft has agreed to rename the new slimmed-down version of Windows it's preparing to release in Europe, after antitrust regulators there balked at the title.

Microsoft announced last month that it intended to use the name "Windows XP Reduced Media Edition" for the program, which has, by order of the European Commission, been stripped of the Media Player that's usually included.

The Commission was concerned that the name would undermine its order by turning consumers off to the new version of Windows and prompting them to stay with the current version, according to reports. So Microsoft is ditching the name and is now busy coming up with a new one, Microsoft spokeswoman Stacy Drake said Friday.

"The Commission has requested that we change the name from the original suggestion," Drake said. "While we believe this name complies (with the commission's orders), we have agreed to make the change. We're working together with the commission to come up with an alternative name."

A representative for the Commission was not immediately available to comment. Recently, however, a Commission representative had threatened further fines if Microsoft did anything to make the new product unattractive, according to several news reports published Friday.

The uninspired name was likely a reflection of Microsoft's feeling about the new product, which the Commission ordered it to release last year as part of the antitrust sanctions it imposed after finding Microsoft guilty of abusive business practices. The Commission also fined the company $648 million.

In addition to lacking a copy of Windows Media Player, the new version of Windows won't be able to do things such as play a CD or MP3 file or transfer music to a portable device--at least not without additional software from another company.

"Given the complexity of implementing the remedies, it's not surprising that there will be issues and questions that go along with the process," Drake said. "Microsoft remains fully committed to implementing the Commission's decision and working with them toward that goal."

Nevertheless, Drake defended the company's original name choice, saying it would have accurately conveyed the difference between the two products. Microsoft is working with its partners to release the new program next month, as scheduled, and has already shipped it to some computer makers in Europe, she added.

Microsoft plans to sell the new product in Europe only and charge the same price that the fuller-featured version fetches there. The company also plans to appeal the Commission's ruling but recently decided not to fight a court order requiring immediate compliance with sanctions, after losing a bid to delay them.

CNET News.com's Ina Fried contributed to this report.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 142 Talkback(s)
Whats In a Name?
What a company wants to call a product should be up to the company. The Social - Communist EU is used to Europe were they like to control the lives of the everyday people. They use nice names to cov... (Read the rest)
Posted by: BuzzSargent Posted on: 03/18/05 You are currently: Logged In | Log out
Ridiculous... ShadeTree   | 01/28/05
Microsoft is not the only to make media players. DonnieBoy   | 01/28/05
true eLurker   | 01/29/05
Well, rapson   | 01/29/05
Well..... NemesisNL   | 01/30/05
but now eLurker   | 01/30/05
Yes it would jheine   | 01/31/05
Accuracy is not the point, according to the EU Martin Marvinski   | 01/30/05
interesting point, that eLurker   | 01/30/05
I disagree Mack DaNife   | 01/31/05
Not incapable rapson   | 01/31/05
Take that to its logical conclusion.. AmusedAtItAll   | 01/31/05
SO The real name of Windows should be... James Schroer   | 01/31/05
really? samp_z   | 03/18/05
Whats In a Name? BuzzSargent   | 03/18/05
With ample funds Jay Cash   | 01/31/05
If the names does not fit, the courts will acquit.. Mike Cox   | 01/28/05
Very Johnnie Cochran. Kudos to you. (NT) Letophoro   | 01/28/05
Amen to that. Grayson Peddie   | 01/29/05
9.7 Real World   | 01/29/05
10 dave95   | 01/29/05
Thanks Mike shallow_diver   | 01/30/05
Nice sincere post Anti_Zealot   | 01/31/05
Mike catches another one shallow_diver   | 01/31/05
Indeed, a master he is Anti_Zealot   | 01/31/05
Apparently not the first time Spoon Jabber   | 01/31/05
Easily fooled Anti_Zealot   | 01/31/05
I don't understand Spoon Jabber   | 01/31/05
8.1. Would have been higher if you'd insulted the French (spit!). (NT) John E Wahd   | 01/31/05
I argued before that the name would not fly DonnieBoy   | 01/28/05
If it had Real's stuff on it ... worknman   | 01/28/05
Why yes, that would be just awful rcf_z   | 01/28/05
The amount of crimes M$ has committed has been a JOKE too Jeff Spicoli   | 01/29/05
Unfair! WhoDaMan   | 01/29/05
Exactly. EVERYONE plays this ball game Jeff Spicoli   | 01/29/05
a spade is a spade gsbtech   | 01/29/05
Suse is bundled with mulimedia capabilities gsbtech   | 01/29/05
Huge difference Linux User 147560   | 01/29/05
Nice try.. d_jedi   | 01/29/05
d_jedi: ABMers have no answer to that NonZealot   | 01/31/05
RE: Nice try.. Linux User 147560   | 01/31/05
Thanks... Mack DaNife   | 01/31/05
Re: Re: Nice try NonZealot   | 01/31/05
RE: Re: Re: Nice try Linux User 147560   | 01/31/05
RE: Nice try.. Michael Kelly   | 01/31/05
Oh and one more thing... Linux User 147560   | 01/29/05
Perhaps the difference is... Richard Flude   | 01/29/05
Please try and pay attention NemesisNL   | 01/30/05
Where is the similarity? AmusedAtItAll   | 02/01/05
And those examples rcf_z   | 01/31/05
Two reasons rapson   | 01/31/05
I don't believe so... MacCanuck   | 02/01/05
Please stop with the patriotism allready NemesisNL   | 01/30/05
It's not patriotism for rcf_z   | 01/31/05
Happens all the time tic swayback   | 01/31/05
Point taken, however.... rcf_z   | 01/31/05
Maybe you weren't paying attention? Jay Cash   | 01/31/05
What I've also noticed rcf_z   | 01/31/05
Gee, how American of you. AmusedAtItAll   | 02/01/05
it is not possible eLurker   | 01/29/05
Let’s not forget the customers dave95   | 01/29/05
well, this is the eu eLurker   | 01/30/05
Not a good analogy for this case dave95   | 01/30/05
From my experience, yes voska   | 01/31/05
Don't know where you live dave95   | 01/31/05
MICROSUCKS ARROGANCE NEVER CHANGES... realitycheck101   | 01/28/05
Re: MICROSUCKS ARROGANCE NEVER CHANGES... ReFoRMaT   | 01/29/05
not gonna happen DarbyOhara   | 01/31/05
Oportunity Anti_Zealot   | 01/31/05
How about IE integration then? DJ FlowFX   | 01/28/05
Re: How about IE integration then? ReFoRMaT   | 01/29/05
No need to make it any more complicated Richard Flude   | 01/29/05
Integrating the browser was an open issue. Anton Philidor   | 01/31/05
Sadly enough I think you are right NemesisNL   | 01/30/05
This just proves AGAIN... ReFoRMaT   | 01/29/05
Re: This just proves AGAIN... ReFoRMaT   | 01/29/05
Proves that people IT Scion   | 01/30/05
we all know I'm no fan of MS BUT mlindl   | 01/29/05
Why not just call it XP Lite?... Jeff Spicoli   | 01/29/05
That's a good idea rapson   | 01/31/05
There IS something missing! mwagner@...  ZDNet | 01/31/05
Of course there is rapson   | 01/31/05
Why keep the name the same voska   | 01/31/05
Go EU! Linux User 147560   | 01/29/05
Yes! Jeff Spicoli   | 01/29/05
but.... gsbtech   | 01/29/05
See you are still confused Linux User 147560   | 01/29/05
Since when.. d_jedi   | 01/29/05
Do you see Linux or Macintosh in the specs? Linux User 147560   | 01/29/05
Woops... jumped the gun... Linux User 147560   | 01/29/05
You can uninstall WMP if you want voska   | 01/31/05
OK what is? Richard Flude   | 01/29/05
Then you should move now Delmont   | 01/30/05
Typical johnnyu   | 01/30/05
Believe it! dave95   | 01/30/05
Sounds like you don't want to live in US StanB   | 01/30/05
India johnnyu   | 01/30/05
Hope you like working for peanuts (NT) Spoon Jabber   | 01/31/05
Move too.... voska   | 01/31/05
we will miss you jeff eLurker   | 01/30/05
Nah rapson   | 01/31/05
Yeah dave95   | 01/31/05
And we are! Spoon Jabber   | 01/31/05
No... rapson   | 01/31/05
On second thought... rapson   | 01/31/05
Only being facetious Carl dave95   | 01/31/05
If... IT Scion   | 01/30/05
call it what it is gsbtech   | 01/29/05
It's the integrating part that bites NemesisNL   | 01/30/05
new ruling - why limit ourselves to mp3's gsbtech   | 01/29/05
FUNNY HOW THE XP THAI EDITION ISN'T CALLED "REDUCED"! Jeff Spicoli   | 01/29/05
WELCOME TO THE NEW WORLD! pablo@...   | 01/29/05
do it but do it right gsbtech   | 01/29/05
When will MS era end? Roving_Reporter   | 01/30/05
But IT Scion   | 01/30/05
exactly!!! eLurker   | 01/30/05
Of course the EC Windows is not expected to sell. Anton Philidor   | 01/31/05
That depends Mack DaNife   | 01/31/05
Just call it Windows XP EU Media Edition FilledOut   | 01/29/05
Actually ... mwagner@...  ZDNet | 01/31/05
Why is the EU.. d_jedi   | 01/29/05
someone already answered this... DarbyOhara   | 01/31/05
Browser wasn't an issue because... Anton Philidor   | 01/31/05
I did read the thread.. d_jedi   | 01/31/05
Wasted effort. IT Scion   | 01/30/05
If that means leave product design alone... Anton Philidor   | 01/31/05
Wouldn't a simpler solution to this madness... BitTwiddler   | 01/31/05
That would be best dave95   | 01/31/05
Turned it down because... Mack DaNife   | 01/31/05
A simpler solution, yes, but ... mwagner@...  ZDNet | 01/31/05
No it's not rapson   | 01/31/05
Microsoft offered just that. Anton Philidor   | 01/31/05
Ironic, isn't it? mwagner@...  ZDNet | 01/31/05
The EC rapson   | 01/31/05
Maybe he'll accept "The Full Monti" Anton Philidor   | 01/31/05
I agreed with you post in manny ways until this Mack DaNife   | 01/31/05
You've described the crux of the issue, yes. Anton Philidor   | 01/31/05
How about... No_Ax_to_Grind   | 01/31/05
Love-hate relationship? Spoon Jabber   | 01/31/05
oh, I get it... Stewart Cannon   | 01/31/05
Or, how about Spoon Jabber   | 01/31/05
Freedom of Product Design wayne@...   | 03/18/05

What do you think?

advertisement
advertisement