On CBS.com: Play Survivor Video Trivia Now
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

By Charles Cooper
Posted on ZDNet News: Apr 22, 2005 5:48:00 PM

Commentary--Getting time with Microsoft's Jim Allchin used to be as easy as gaining an audience with the pope. But these days Microsoft's No. 3 executive is popping up all over the place--even reworking his busy schedule to sup with (gasp!) bloggers.

It's not a role that comes naturally to the normally reclusive Allchin. A brainy but reserved uber-geek, Allchin would much prefer hashing over code questions with developers than sit down with a bunch of infernally annoying reporters. But the company's future depends on his transformation into a veritable Mr. Accessible--and a persuasive Mr. Accessible, at that.

Can he do it? More than Bill Gates, more than Steve Ballmer, it's Allchin who must convince opinion makers and the all-important OEM community that Longhorn, the code name for the next major operating system from Microsoft, is worth the wait. And then the rest of us have to be convinced that Longhorn is the next must-have product in their lives.

Mac owners--yours truly among them--will no doubt chuckle at the audacity of some of the coming claims. Rest assured there will be no paucity of hyperbole in the remaining year-and-a-half run-up to the operating system's debut (assuming Microsoft hits its self-imposed deadline.)

Mac owners--yours truly among them--will no doubt chuckle at the audacity of some of the coming claims.
It's going to be that way because every segment of the PC food chain is desperate for a megahit out of Microsoft. With memories of the go-go days a fading memory, they would like nothing better than a killer operating system that ignites a furious upgrade cycle--if not a mad spree of impulse buying.

The company, which plans to unleash a massive marketing blitz around Longhorn, needs to create a bigger stir than when it last rolled out a "major" OS upgrade in 2001 with Windows XP. Through no fault of its own, Microsoft's launch coincided with a tech spending slowdown and an accompanying economic recession. The bigger problem: XP was only marginally more interesting than Windows 98 and no amount of marketing hoopla could convince otherwise.

Microsoft began publicly discussing the Longhorn project in 2002, but its engineers were already tinkering before then. Work on some parts of the OS (like the recently excised WinFS) actually dates back more than 10 years (roughly coinciding with Allchin's stewardship of Windows).

When Allchin came to town last week, he was in prime demo form. One thing Microsoft does well--Allchin, in particular--is demonstrate its products. (The one time that wasn't the case happened to take place in inconvenient public view at the company's antitrust trial in Washington.)

At this early juncture, Longhorn leaves a positive impression. Groundbreaking? I'll reserve judgment for later.
At this early juncture, Longhorn leaves a positive impression. Groundbreaking? I'll reserve judgment for later. Some of the features bore similarities to Apple Computer's Mac OS X Tiger, which goes on sale later this month. (One critic by the name of Steve Jobs went even further. "They are shamelessly copying us," he declared during the company’s annual meeting on Thursday.) Whatever its intellectual origin, the new OS clearly marks an improvement over XP and, if you believe Allchin, will go a long way toward answer lingering user complaints about ease-of-use and computer security. In the same breath, I should point out that Microsoft has created many of those same ease-of-use and security issues, but better late than never.

Two big challenges remain. Microsoft has rarely shipped its operating systems on time and Longhorn is no exception. Allchin's final legacy at the company rests on his ability to pull this one over the goal line on time. Without getting into details, he suggested that Microsoft would make sure OEMs have copies in hand well before the December 2006 product debut. An entire industry will be planning around that promise. If that date slips, you’re talking about disaster.

Microsoft also needs to turn out a "wow" product with as many useful bells and whistles as it can. This is part computer science, part guesswork, but Microsoft still hasn't produced a "wow" version of Windows. If Longhorn doesn't produce the goods, not even a gazillion dollars in marketing funds will make a difference. This is about more than managing the message.

biography
Charles Cooper is the executive editor of commentary at CNET News.com.

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 117 Talkback(s)
Longhorn is Big Brother in Disguise
Pardon the bad spelling, but Mr. Gates black box is another step away from open source and he's trying to put the locks on anybody who won't play the MS way.... (Read the rest)
Posted by: support@... Posted on: 04/29/05 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
What?  FreeBSD | 04/22/05
Doesn't matter to me either.  Immanuel Tranz-Mischen | 04/23/05
Doesn't matter to me either.  probert100 | 04/26/05
Why Longhorn matters  Loverock Davidson | 04/22/05
Which obviously implies..  Jeff Spicoli | 04/22/05
What you said  Loverock Davidson | 04/22/05
Was about to say the same Jeffey  dave95 | 04/22/05
False dichotomy  Yagotta B. Kidding | 04/22/05
You're right who am I kidding!  dave95 | 04/22/05
Their marketing will probably include  Hugh Jass | 04/22/05
Talking about a disaster?  nucrash | 04/22/05
Microsoft has extended support...  Anton Philidor | 04/22/05
What?  NonZealot | 04/22/05
Interest is differnt than functionality  voska | 04/22/05
I was also going to say that  Jeff Spicoli | 04/22/05
Agree mostly  Jeff Spicoli | 04/22/05
Nice post  NonZealot | 04/22/05
thank you ma man  Jeff Spicoli | 04/22/05
Lock down  NonZealot | 04/22/05
Installing SP2  Anton Philidor | 04/22/05
You don't have to overdo security settings...  Anton Philidor | 04/22/05
Not too concerned about whether it 'matters'  Real World | 04/22/05
But..  Jeff Spicoli | 04/22/05
He bought a Dell therefore new PC in 1.5 years  ITGuy04 | 04/22/05
Which PC seller would you go with?  Jeff Spicoli | 04/22/05
Sony VAIO's are supposed to be nice, but  Hugh Jass | 04/22/05
What? No Mac?  Real World | 04/22/05
A Mac mini?  Ken_z | 04/23/05
Bump his RAM to 512, he'll be happy longer  itanalyst | 04/22/05
I would but he really doesn't run much of anything  Jeff Spicoli | 04/22/05
Re: But..  Real World | 04/23/05
We're all 10 years behind ...  Eggs Ackley_z | 04/22/05
moronic  Tommy Gun | 04/22/05
An open letter to Tommy Gun..  Mike Cox | 04/22/05
MIKE Seriously!!! You have me on the floor (10)  dave95 | 04/22/05
I thought that was awesome too!  Jeff Spicoli | 04/22/05
that was a 10!!!!  xshakes | 04/22/05
9.5  Real World | 04/22/05
8.6 --- Definitely a good one. (nt)  Plain Logic | 04/22/05
Please....  DebianDog | 04/22/05
hmmmm  dave95 | 04/22/05
Well now that you mention it...  Linux User 147560 | 04/22/05
Have fun  DarthRidiculous | 04/22/05
Tommy Gun... small calibre... big bore  MacCanuck | 04/22/05
And in this corner  Yagotta B. Kidding | 04/22/05
It's Gun vs. Cox!  Jeff Spicoli | 04/22/05
Marketing is their key...  RicD_ | 04/22/05
Another follower of the flys.  Outside T. Box | 04/25/05
Windows is great if...  azucaro | 04/25/05
Yep, they could just use Linspire instead  FilledOut | 04/25/05
Only matters to M$'s bottom line  drichards1953 | 04/22/05
Why Longhorn matters to me...  Mike Cox | 04/22/05
Mike You owe me a new keyboard  NoDogs | 04/22/05
extolled  DebianDog | 04/22/05
9.5  Taz_z | 04/22/05
Penultimate  tic swayback | 04/22/05
8.75  Real World | 04/22/05
Gurus bwahahaha See pics inside Definately a 8.650931  Squawkbox | 04/22/05
Post above is in response to Mike Cox  Squawkbox | 04/22/05
MS big advertising campaign  alterego_z | 04/22/05
I'm sure I missed something  Yagotta B. Kidding | 04/22/05
Please explain  NonZealot | 04/22/05
Was the article about home users?  j.m.galvin | 04/22/05
post is to squawk  MIS Master | 04/22/05
My, my, the green of envy is showing.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 04/22/05
Envy of What??? Another POS Security-Riddled OS By Gates/Baldmer?  itanalyst | 04/22/05
Read the post above his...  Hugh Jass | 04/22/05
Nice! I thought the same thing.... (NT)  Hugh Jass | 04/22/05
Yeah but I ain't lyin  Squawkbox | 04/23/05
What fruit will the tree bear?  No_Ax_to_Grind | 04/22/05
The glints of straightforward honesty..  Jeff Spicoli | 04/22/05
If you put down the Linux glasses you'll see I always am.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 04/22/05
Axey, you switched to Linux or OSX, didn't you? wink (NT)  Hugh Jass | 04/22/05
He doesn't use Linux  Michael Kelly | 04/22/05
He'll be a Linux user soon  Hugh Jass | 04/22/05
Sorry you are wrong...  No_Ax_to_Grind | 04/22/05
my god jeff happy  toxicfreak | 04/23/05
Disagree - just a little  j.m.galvin | 04/22/05
I'm Guessing The Microsoft Tree Will Bear Sh*t Sandwiches  itanalyst | 04/22/05
With any luck  tic swayback | 04/22/05
Convincing OEMs is the easy part.  CobraA1 | 04/23/05
Why OEM's may not be so easy this time.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 04/23/05
RE: Why OEM's may not be so easy this time.  CobraA1 | 04/24/05
Sounds swell, but isn't sound.  nucrash | 04/25/05
More time to install?  CobraA1 | 04/25/05
8.5 "tech suave OEM's" LOL what a hoot.  Outside T. Box | 04/25/05
Matters to some, not to others  FilledOut | 04/22/05
Longhorn will matter in the future  MIS Master | 04/22/05
Your trolling sucks dude  Jeff Spicoli | 04/22/05
Longhorn Predicted Release Schedule  itanalyst | 04/22/05
Oh Come On Jeff, I Was Expecting You To Comment On This!  itanalyst | 04/22/05
Thats Correct  mobileomega | 04/23/05
I love it!  DarthRidiculous | 04/24/05
Pulling over the goal line  tic swayback | 04/22/05
Microsoft's New Mantra: It Just Works.....  itanalyst | 04/22/05
So I read the article and here is what I have to say...  Linux User 147560 | 04/22/05
Don't forget -  Hugh Jass | 04/22/05
It ONLY matters to  michael-t | 04/22/05
every MS user  Richard Flude | 04/22/05
LongSteer dosen't exist!  Reverend MacFellow | 04/22/05
You're right, no one has ever heard of LongSteer  No_Ax_to_Grind | 04/22/05
All: Face west, bow down, and repeat after me...  Plain Logic | 04/22/05
Bow to the south  FilledOut | 04/23/05
Longhorn will succeed  xshakes | 04/23/05
Why Foghorn doesn't matter  DarthRidiculous | 04/23/05
hmmm  IT Scion | 04/23/05
Pass the koolaid please  DarthRidiculous | 04/24/05
It's a shame  IT Scion | 04/25/05
Stop i'm dyin................  kstalker | 04/23/05
This I would expect from a MAC user --  Joe Blow_z | 04/23/05
Your standards are indead low  DarthRidiculous | 04/23/05
Stable if you only played solitaire.  steventwill | 04/28/05
Of course it matters...but...  IT Scion | 04/23/05
"marginally more interesting?"  doctormoriarty | 04/25/05
~~marketing hype ~~  jfoote | 04/25/05
It matters only if Longhorn will not require multiple protective programs  steventwill | 04/28/05
Longhorn is Big Brother in Disguise  support@... | 04/29/05

What do you think?

advertisement
Click Here

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

SmartPlanet

Click Here