On CHOW: Why do ONIONS make you cry?
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

By Ingrid Marson, News.com
Posted on ZDNet News: May 16, 2006 2:18:00 PM

The International Organization for Standardization is unlikely to adopt Microsoft Office Open XML format, now that it has approved the OpenDocument Format, according to analyst group Gartner.

There is a 70 percent probability that the standards organization will not approve multiple XML document formats, according to a research note published by Gartner last week. It also predicted, with the same probability, that "by 2010, ODF (OpenDocument Format) document exchange will be required by 50 percent of government and 20 percent of commercial organizations."

Microsoft submitted its Office Open XML file formats to the European standards body, ECMA International, last year, as a prelude to seeking ISO standardization.

In its research note, "ISO Approval of OASIS OpenDocument is a Blow to Microsoft," Gartner advised vendors to "seek opportunities to leverage ODF." However, it warned that a migration to applications that support ODF could be costly.

"The migration will not be inexpensive, and will involve compatibility issues when exchanging documents with Microsoft Office users. If you need compatibility with Microsoft Office formats or cannot cost-justify a migration, lobby Microsoft to support ODF and look for plug-ins that allow you to open and save ODF files from within Microsoft applications," Gartner advised.

Although Gartner thinks it is unlikely that Microsoft's formats will be approved by ISO, the European Commission seems less sure. A couple of days after OpenDocument's ISO approval, sources at the Commission told ZDNet UK that it is unlikely to recommend the document format "in case we will have two ISO standards at a later point in time."

The aim of all the current wrangling over XML data formats by standards bodies is to try and move towards interoperability among any type of application, including databases, search engines and Web services.

ODF is supported by various applications, including Sun Microsystems' StarOffice, Google's Writely, IBM Workplace and OpenOffice.org, an open-source spinoff of StarOffice. Microsoft has refused to add ODF support to Microsoft Office, but has agreed to support interoperability with the format.

Ingrid Marson of ZDNet UK reported from London.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 82 Talkback(s)
Yes, a wordprocessor
Absolutely, I have seen Excel used just like Word. To type documents, letters, and book reports. I have seen people do the same with Notepad, not simple stuff, but long documents.... (Read the rest)
Posted by: TheHonestTruth Posted on: 05/17/06 You are currently: Logged In | Log out
theres no way not of this world   | 05/16/06
I don't agree. nomorems   | 05/16/06
Have you compared the two specs? A.Sinic   | 05/16/06
Have you compared the two licenses? Roger Ramjet   | 05/16/06
Pounds of paper Yagotta B. Kidding   | 05/16/06
ODF... Support aallord   | 05/16/06
Why is the spec slimmer? John Le'Brecage   | 05/16/06
For reasons of nomorems   | 05/16/06
Support will be provided by others. mighetto   | 05/16/06
Java speed smcnutt@...   | 05/16/06
What? techboy_z   | 05/16/06
Depends what version you are using Scrat   | 05/17/06
Extension of the penulties from the last US antitrust case... nomorems   | 05/16/06
The Story I believe read... aallord   | 05/16/06
Gartner is completely clueless No_Ax_to_Grind   | 05/16/06
Do you work for them? Roger Ramjet   | 05/16/06
If I did, they would be right more often. No_Ax_to_Grind   | 05/16/06
No_ Window_of_Doubt_to_ Grind - NT raycote   | 05/17/06
Good one ! - hope your point will be taken ! - NT raycote   | 05/17/06
You're President of Gartner? itanalyst   | 05/16/06
He is the armchair President - NT raycote   | 05/17/06
Ah, yes Yagotta B. Kidding   | 05/16/06
Gee, do you need me to use smaller words? No_Ax_to_Grind   | 05/16/06
Envy? Yagotta B. Kidding   | 05/16/06
You might accuse Gartner of stating the obvious, but they are right more DonnieBoy   | 05/16/06
#1 prediction that Windows would be secure by now... nomorems   | 05/16/06
Every_ Ax_Grinding_Away - But not much to say! - NT raycote   | 05/17/06
you are clueless Linux Geek   | 05/16/06
NWOR (nt) No_Ax_to_Grind   | 05/16/06
I quite agree Yagotta B. Kidding   | 05/16/06
That's not fair - everyone continues to respond to you! - NT raycote   | 05/17/06
Still, we don't need two XML fomats, one will do just fine. DonnieBoy   | 05/16/06
We? No_Ax_to_Grind   | 05/16/06
No, just speaking for the intelligent and rational people among us. DonnieBoy   | 05/16/06
Ask first. (NT) Anton Philidor   | 05/16/06
Proof in the pudding second... nomorems   | 05/16/06
He's stealing your show :( - NT raycote   | 05/17/06
When thinking of Gartner one word comes to mind: Y2K smcnutt@...   | 05/16/06
Yet another inane troll - YAIT Fred Fredrickson   | 05/16/06
Ahhh, memories... Zeppo9191   | 05/16/06
Well, you are right, but we are talking billions of dollars here. DonnieBoy   | 05/16/06
Washington State will Require ISO mighetto   | 05/16/06
If nothing else, governments and large corporations will use this to DonnieBoy   | 05/16/06
I wonder how they figure? JoeMama_z   | 05/16/06
Man, we are talking generic office suites here. MS Office is nothing more DonnieBoy   | 05/16/06
If you believe that garbage... No_Ax_to_Grind   | 05/16/06
We are always enlightened Yagotta B. Kidding   | 05/16/06
And, you don't know squat about what the average user needs. DonnieBoy   | 05/16/06
Power Users Can't Hold Back Tide jdearl   | 05/16/06
Office as a Platform A.Sinic   | 05/16/06
and why am I NOT surpised by your lack of knowledge. nomorems   | 05/16/06
Every one with a different opinion than No_Ax is ignorant raycote   | 05/17/06
You are right (to some degree) JoeMama_z   | 05/16/06
OpenOffice and MS Office are really about the same, so if they didn't like DonnieBoy   | 05/16/06
That can't be right Yagotta B. Kidding   | 05/16/06
Somewhat right Tony Agudo   | 05/16/06
Right, I agree there, the new version of MS Office will be completely DonnieBoy   | 05/16/06
Yes it can Fred Fredrickson   | 05/16/06
Simple... John Le'Brecage   | 05/16/06
thanks for the reply... JoeMama_z   | 05/16/06
Just about nobody? techboy_z   | 05/16/06
I use open office... JoeMama_z   | 05/16/06
Realistic but not non-existent techboy_z   | 05/17/06
Corporations and large corporations, you will get HUGE discounts from MS. DonnieBoy   | 05/16/06
How dare the International Standards Organization NOT to michael_t   | 05/16/06
Following ISO A.Sinic   | 05/17/06
To speak the truth michael_t   | 05/17/06
PDF Interoperability... interested_amateur@...   | 05/16/06
This is not a problem for Microsoft... John Le'Brecage   | 05/16/06
Saving Don the trouble Yagotta B. Kidding   | 05/16/06
Actually, I was hoping for Anton... John Le'Brecage   | 05/16/06
You get what you pay for Yagotta B. Kidding   | 05/16/06
I'm a ZD poster, John, not a rhetorician. IronCladChicken   | 05/17/06
please, no, not Anton barsteward   | 05/16/06
Implement? TheHonestTruth   | 05/16/06
PDF and ODF's purposes are different Tony Agudo   | 05/16/06
Just a quick response TheHonestTruth   | 05/17/06
Excel used as a word processor? Tony Agudo   | 05/17/06
Yes, a wordprocessor TheHonestTruth   | 05/17/06
PDF? Yagotta B. Kidding   | 05/16/06
John, One of the saner posts here . . . Thanks (nt) Bit's_Conscience   | 05/16/06
Why do ODF supporters insist on count BOTH StarOffice and OpenOffice.org hornerea   | 05/17/06

What do you think?

advertisement
advertisement

Ultraportables

advertisement
Click Here