On CNET: Sonos leaks new CR200 remote control
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

By ZDNN Staff
Posted on ZDNet News: Jul 31, 2007 7:21:00 PM

Rap singer Eminem has accused Apple of copyright infringement in a multimillion-dollar lawsuit, according to a story in The Detroit News.

Eminem's music publishers have not given Apple permission to offer the artist's music for download, according to the report in Tuesday's paper, although Eminem's music is available through the Apple's iTunes Store.

Apple pays a portion of the revenue it collects from Eminem downloads to Universal Music Group, which distributes the music, but not to Eminem's publishers, the News reported. Eight Mile Style and Martin Affiliated, the companies representing Eminem, demand that Apple stop offering downloads.

The newspaper suggested that the problem is caused by the confusion over who owns the rights to downloads. Apparently, Eminem is asserting that record companies do not hold these rights exclusively.

Eminem has tangled in court with Apple before. Eight Mile Style and Martin Affiliated sued Apple in 2004 over the rapper's song "Lose Yourself," which Apple used in a TV commercial. The case was settled out of court.

Owen Sloane of Berger Kahn, an entertainment lawyer who has represented such artists as Steve Winwood, Barry Manilow and Stevie Nicks, said that he expects more entertainers will go to court to demand a larger slice of the digital pie. Music publishers have also expressed dissatisfaction at the way music royalties are distributed.

"All the publishers are rankled that they have to go after the record labels to collect their fees," Sloan said. "Sometimes these fees may not be accounted for properly. The publishers would prefer to collect directly from the source instead of the labels."

Apple did not respond to an interview request.

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 106 Talkback(s)
Own the Labels
I can think of 4 or 5 Rock groups that own the record labels that they make their music for, which cuts out the middle man.

Just this year, Ozzy Osbourne cut his latest record at HIS own studio... (Read the rest)
Posted by: a_ambuehlsr@... Posted on: 09/13/07 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Message has been deleted.  Arm A. Geddon | 07/31/07
Yeah, imagine wanting to be paid for their work.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 07/31/07
Then maybe they should sue their Recording Label  voska | 07/31/07
and one word for you...  Arm A. Geddon | 07/31/07
Wouldn't that all hinge  No_Ax_to_Grind | 07/31/07
Opps, lost part of it  No_Ax_to_Grind | 07/31/07
That's the point  voska | 08/01/07
Permission is the whole story  Freebird54 | 08/02/07
It's still up to the label.  Resuna | 08/01/07
You are wrong here..  lenohere | 08/01/07
You are wrong here..  bmore_bro69@... | 08/01/07
paid FAIRLY????!!  macbill | 08/01/07
Are you people Stupid or something  bergmystr | 08/01/07
Why shouldn't they feel that way?  bpolhemus@... | 08/01/07
re: stop making money  Arm A. Geddon | 08/01/07
Fair is in the eye of the beholder...  name23 | 08/01/07
If you think Steve Jobs...  bpolhemus@... | 08/01/07
Not following?  jt@... | 08/01/07
Right, you're not following  Mike Hunt | 08/02/07
Music licensing is different  rdbjr | 08/02/07
Let's look at widgets  mad tabby | 08/03/07
sure and they also want to get paid even if they'll be dead...  Arm A. Geddon | 07/31/07
correction  Arm A. Geddon | 07/31/07
copyright extensions...  conspicuouschick | 07/31/07
a little research  Arm A. Geddon | 07/31/07
did ya learn anything....  conspicuouschick | 08/01/07
Copyright do matter to musicians  voska | 08/01/07
re: impress me?  Arm A. Geddon | 08/01/07
Copyright Law  name23 | 08/01/07
re: Copyright Law  Arm A. Geddon | 08/01/07
You didn't see the artists complaining  voska | 08/01/07
Certainly, and my farm ground  No_Ax_to_Grind | 07/31/07
I don't think so  voska | 08/01/07
oh really?  macbill | 08/01/07
is this the real No_Axe?  Arm A. Geddon | 08/01/07
they should sue the fans  swizz216 | 08/01/07
Silly Rabbit  bmore_bro69@... | 08/01/07
guess I'm a 49yr kid. ( nt)  Arm A. Geddon | 08/01/07
Who's being greedy?  mwagner@...ZDNet Moderator | 08/01/07
re: Who's being greedy?  Arm A. Geddon | 08/01/07
Do you work for free?  jt@... | 08/01/07
re: working for free  Arm A. Geddon | 08/01/07
seems like Apple has a history of using whatever they want and paying a  wessonjoe | 07/31/07
Apple has history of taking what it wants  mitch@... | 08/01/07
Despite all of the modern day hippies...  fr0thy2. | 08/01/07
i don't feel sorry for apple they are the king of SUE the way i see it  SO.CAL Guy | 08/01/07
Eminem is a Microsoft shareholder  mlindl | 07/31/07
A company today has to clearly define  Boot_Agnostic | 08/01/07
People, people, people...  BitTwiddler | 08/01/07
erm. no wait  fred_gmail | 08/01/07
That doesn't make sense  voska | 08/01/07
Ultimately, Eminem signed a contract ...  mwagner@...ZDNet Moderator | 08/01/07
Apple doesn't have to seek out owners  maxsnorkel | 08/01/07
Really.  DNSB | 08/01/07
"Music" Company?  lmenningen | 08/01/07
Perhaps but the "artist" makes the deal in the first place  Laff | 08/01/07
What?  xxn1927 | 08/01/07
They can  voska | 08/01/07
I wonder if this might work in Apple's favor....?  Laff | 08/01/07
If Eminem is correct about his contract...  mrlinux | 08/01/07
If Eminem is correct about his contract...  bmore_bro69@... | 08/01/07
The devil's in the details  DNSB | 08/01/07
Eminem's problem is with Universal, not Apple  criderja | 08/01/07
Eminem's problem is with Universal, not Apple  bmore_bro69@... | 08/01/07
I don't think the contract matters to Apple  voska | 08/01/07
Two words  fmg9800 | 08/01/07
Excellent analogy!  tikigawd | 08/01/07
Goodbye record lables  mames1701 | 08/01/07
Nope - not a chance ...  mwagner@...ZDNet Moderator | 08/01/07
Whoa!  caburlingame | 08/01/07
Goodbye Record Labels  tdoom | 08/02/07
Good or bad -  Timpraetor | 08/01/07
arrrgh  Timpraetor | 08/01/07
Who the hell is Eminem was my first instinctive response  labarker | 08/01/07
Eminem  dmcewan@... | 08/01/07
Amen!!!  Mr_Wizard | 08/01/07
And so does Universal  name23 | 08/01/07
Maybe Eminem should be sued  dhammond@... | 08/01/07
Suing the wrong target  ekivemark | 08/01/07
His "Music", His Contracts  xcali | 08/01/07
Eminem Detractors unite  fmg9800 | 08/01/07
What Next.  John_Carter | 08/01/07
Broadcast Music  jwmares | 08/01/07
Asked a lawyer here  DNSB | 08/01/07
Here, ignorance is bliss!  tonym87@... | 08/01/07
Awwwww, Mr. Wannabe rapper is trying to remain relevant!  usc1801 | 08/01/07
Eminem = garbage, who cares?  kraterz | 08/01/07
Bravo Kraterz!  tonym87@... | 08/02/07
great big yawner.  jlafitte | 08/01/07
cake and eat it too  empty_z | 08/01/07
so...  inertman@... | 08/02/07
Greed on steroids  mlklepac@... | 08/02/07
Cost of living going up, Eminem needs his minimum wage increased  Boot_Agnostic | 08/02/07
What about the fans?  smileyface522 | 08/02/07
re: What about the fans?  deepee912 | 08/02/07
royalty percentage  InsaneWayne | 08/02/07
Greed  Quantum Rift | 08/02/07
Such childish behavior, why?  T1Oracle | 08/02/07
What is REALLY needed...  blarman_z | 08/03/07
****APPLAUSE******  mad tabby | 08/03/07
Hate music  vger_z | 08/03/07
Bravo! vger_z  tonym87@... | 08/07/07
Seems to me the real moral of this story...  rich12321@... | 08/07/07
Artists should self-publish and let labels go extinct  cmfnyc | 09/06/07
Record Labels???  dbisse@... | 09/07/07
Own the Labels  a_ambuehlsr@... | 09/13/07

What do you think?

advertisement
advertisement

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

SmartPlanet

  • Thought-provoking progressive ideas on diverse topics that intersect with technology, business, and life, and matter to the world at large. Visit SmartPlanet
  • More from IBM
  • Innovate your business' process model, play against the market, compete against others on our scoreboards and WIN! Try INNOV8 2.0: A BPM Simulator
  • Enabling Real-World Business Transformation through IBM Service Management Read the EMA Analyst Report
advertisement
Click Here