On mySimon: Pretend and Play Doctor Set
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

By Seb Janacek silicon.com
Posted on ZDNet News: Mar 05, 2009 6:07:27 AM

As netbooks continue their inexorable rise up the wish lists of gadget hounds, businesses and ordinary folk alike, the clamor for Apple to join the market continues to increase from all sides.

That's despite both Steve Jobs and interim CEO Tim Cook categorically denying that Apple is about to enter what has been described as a 'nascent' market.

Jobs has also suggested that the iPod Touch and iPhone is in essence a kind of netbook, based on what they are commonly used for. He's not fooling anyone though.

Starting from essentially zero market penetration in late 2007, by the end of last year, roughly 10 million netbooks have shipped, according to IDC. They now account for seven per cent of all portable PCs, an extraordinary growth rate in a short time.

See also: Installing Mac OS X on a Dell Mini 9 netbook
New iMac and Mac Minis on the lab bench
Battle for best high-end Mac OS X netbook

So what defines a netbook?

Jobs may have a point in that the Touch is great for web browsing and email, is lightweight, has wireless and is relatively cheap.

It's not ideal for office or productivity tasks. I'm a fan of the soft keyboard and will happily 'tap' out a hundred words or so of an email but a longer document is painful.

But at what cost? It's a loaded question.

Firstly, as Jobs claimed late last year, Apple doesn't know how to make a $500 Mac that 'isn't a piece of junk', as it's not in the company's DNA. Consider the current Mac Mini. A mere $100 above the $500 price point and it looks overpriced, probably because it is.

Secondly, Apple would undoubtedly sell bucket loads of shiny units if it did release a sub $500 OS X-powered netbook.

However, given the company would be competing in an aggressive and increasingly populated market with price being the key differentiating factor, its margins would be cut and its profits would suffer. An anathema to the Apple board.

Furthermore, sales of netbooks would cannibalize sales of higher margin, higher specification MacBooks, again resulting in more loss of profit.

Lest we forget, Apple has somewhere in the order of $28bn in cash thanks to its aforementioned high profit margin strategy and is well placed to sit out tough economic times and come out smiling the other side without compromising the same strategy.

Appealing to a customer who focused solely on price makes no sense to Apple. Someone who cares solely about price has a casual interest in quality and that is another anathema to the Apple brand.

Perhaps the very best reason to explain why Apple isn't bothering with netbooks for the time being was illustrated in a report from retail analysts Channel Checkers.

The firm surveyed Apple stores to track sales of iPod and Macs along with business trends at Apple stores in the US. According to their survey, 73 per cent of respondents said the top-selling computer was the MacBook Pro.

The top selling Mac in most Apple Stores surveyed was the high end MacBook Pro. The highest specification notebook Apple produces. In the US it retails between $2,000 and $2,800. Hardly low-cost netbook territory.

As we stand there are two reasons Apple isn't selling netbooks.

Firstly, Apple doesn't make netbooks because it can't work out how to make a notebook that can compete in that $500 space.

Secondly and more importantly, Apple doesn't make a netbook because, right now, it doesn't need to.

This article was originally published on silicon.com.

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 88 Talkback(s)
Get us in the Apple Market
As most people i would love to buy a Macbook Pro.. BUT whats the issue? Well, for me being on Traineeship wages it is money... If Apple were to release a sub $500 macbook i would be able to get into t... (Read the rest)
Posted by: djdirty Posted on: 07/07/09  (Edited: 07/07/09 @ 03:25) You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Netbook = cheap Apple = Overpriced  anthony_hunt | 03/05/09
Again, Apple would NEVER compete on price in the netbook category.  DonnieBoy | 03/05/09
Apple already has a netbook...  mrlinux | 03/05/09
True! Very thin, but a bit bigger screen. I think that Apple will come out  DonnieBoy | 03/05/09
Apple does not equate overpriced  spotvin | 03/05/09
RE:Apple does not equate overpriced  richdave | 03/05/09
I still run a G3...at $50  marcomar | 03/07/09
Dunno about Macs  wolf_z | 03/07/09
A foolish thought.  mjolnar@... | 05/07/09
the other side  coffeeshark | 03/05/09
Actually, Apple could make VERY good money at 599, and that is double the  DonnieBoy | 03/05/09
How do you know they could make "VERY good money"?  GuidingLight | 03/05/09
not their margin  coffeeshark | 03/05/09
Money to finance itself  setatakahashi@... | 03/05/09
Poor margins on netbooks.  DotNetPgmr | 03/05/09
Bingo. You are right, Apple will NOT compete on price in the Netbook market  DonnieBoy | 03/05/09
I'm not sure you understand the point of a netbook  MissingMatter | 03/05/09
that's only half of it though  Day24 | 03/05/09
More Likely...  Jkirk3279 | 03/06/09
Why would I pay that kind of money  mjolnar@... | 05/07/09
Not really...  Eleutherios | 03/07/09
Then it would NOT be a Netbook,  GuidingLight | 03/05/09
Apple's iPhone & iPod Touch ARE their "netbooks"  Mikael_z | 03/06/09
Exactly!  theoxygenthief | 03/06/09
Apple will NOT compete on price  aussieblnd@... | 03/06/09
Still, Apple WILL have a Netbook at the right time, thought they will not  DonnieBoy | 03/05/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  Ronin1 | 03/05/09
Have you heard of outsourcing??  DonnieBoy | 03/05/09
Apple IS in an open market  rahbm | 03/05/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  mrlinux | 03/05/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  simon@... | 03/05/09
larger form factor dontTouch with a wheel control instead of a keyboard?  pupkin_z | 03/05/09
Dell rep has given us Mini 9's...  Mike Cox | 03/05/09
Bless You  DannyO_0x98 | 03/05/09
Tough Irony  Mikael_z | 03/06/09
I, personally like the idea of running over an  mjolnar@... | 05/07/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  tmsmqwx | 03/05/09
Even if Apple made a netbook, they couldn't compete on price. [nt]  olePigeon | 03/05/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  DannyO_0x98 | 03/05/09
Aready happening  tmsmqwx | 03/06/09
Seems to me, it would be a good way  formerbberrynowiphone | 03/05/09
Not Apple  mathcreative | 03/06/09
At $399  jongunn@... | 05/08/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  OrlandoHatch | 03/05/09
its all about the user experience  mac_user_1992 | 03/05/09
Anyone notice...  CowLauncher | 03/05/09
And Audi and Daimler should...  TimmyB | 03/05/09
Good analogy  mjolnar@... | 05/07/09
open your eyes  adr5@... | 05/07/09
Poor Value?  Heathen89 | 05/07/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  chromeronin | 03/05/09
Why should they?  **owly** | 03/05/09
because people want netbooks!  andreas.tanzer@... | 03/06/09
re: because people want netbooks!  cmcfarla | 04/09/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  vivisep@... | 03/05/09
Apple DOES make a netbook  theoxygenthief | 03/05/09
iPod touch does NOT serve netbook niche  bw@... | 04/13/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  chelless@... | 03/05/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  vilppuu@... | 03/05/09
I am an old fart  tekWatcher | 03/06/09
Netbook with Ubuntu  asg749d@... | 03/06/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  asg749d@... | 03/06/09
Remember... People Laughed at the Newton!  camcost@... | 03/06/09
Who cares about Apple? get a TouchBook for $299  gmeader | 03/06/09
Netbooks aren't just about price.  roystonlodge | 03/06/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  mikefulton1963 | 03/06/09
Apple gets MY money. Be Gone MS freaks!  No More Microsoft Software Ever! | 03/06/09
Netbook Hackintosh  DavidGerard | 03/08/09
Mac's aren't over priced (in general)  Fred Fredrickson | 03/08/09
Bottom dollar... QTP  konkreet | 03/09/09
What fantasy land does the author live in?  Spiritusindomit@... | 03/09/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  SantaCruzRed | 03/09/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  jeff.fostermedia@... | 04/09/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  dheady@... | 04/09/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  hackhavn | 04/09/09
You can't get a decent computer for $500  Laraine Anne Barker | 04/09/09
It will be completely different  mayadanteamihan | 04/09/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  darije.djokic@... | 04/10/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  eye4bear | 04/11/09
RE: I don't think you understand the point of a netbook...  dbneeley | 05/07/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  christudas_dai | 05/07/09
What about iPods???  jsmit24@... | 05/07/09
It's about value, not quality  adr5@... | 05/07/09
Bingo!  gypkap@... | 07/07/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  peripo | 05/14/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  rparker009 | 07/07/09
RE: Why Apple doesn't make a netbook  rowinms | 07/07/09
Get us in the Apple Market  djdirty | 07/07/09

What do you think?

advertisement
advertisement

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Enterprise Applications

  • Check out some of the easiest and most powerful ways to boost productivity while saving money on your application infrastructure. See ZDNet's comprehensive Enterprise Application resource center, now!
  • New Online Dashboard
  • Read about top issues IT decision-makers face every day, plus get cost effective solutions to real life IT problems. Oracle Topline